Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bob's avatar

He did get one thing right when he mentioned "their war." On October 7, his community carried on as if nothing was happening because none of them were receiving emergency call ups. When yomtov was over and it was clear that no charedi yishuvim had been attacked and there were no charedi casualties, they breathed a sigh of relief that their lives could go on as before and they did on October 8, 9 etc. Their yeshivot carried on as normal without additional tefilot or learning and bein hazmanim was not changed.

There is a way to change this, particularly given the manpower shortages in the IDF. Every town with close to zero enlistment such as Beitar illit and Kiryat Sefer should have all govt run security removed from them. After all, it's not their war and they have the merit of their Torah learning to protect them anyway. This will at least free up some soldiers to be deployed elsewhere and suddenly, you can be sure, it will become "their war" as well when they have to take responsibility for their own security.

Norman Kahan's avatar

Can only appreciate your honesty and your commitment in keeping us informed about the Chareidi situation. They are a burden on Clal Yisraeli and will be so until the politicians fulfill their duties to the people and start to deal effectively with the situation

8 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?