Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Weaver's avatar

"What's going to be?!" "This will mean the destruction of Torah!!" seems to be the go-to line in defense of current Israeli chareidi status quo, which is of course silly and ahistorical. (And, incidentally, it's not as if the current chareidi system is producing many gedolim, either.)

Somehow (a) the daati leumi, Anglos, Sephardim, and all other frum people in Israel, (b) virtually all American frum Jews (including in the yeshiva world), and (c) most of the Jewish people throughout our entire history somehow managed to work and be Torah Jews.

Expand full comment
Shaul Shapira's avatar

When I first saw this post in my inbox, I got excited. I thought *you* were going to be the one accusing people of committing murder for going to weddings https://www.rationalistjudaism.com/p/the-chassidic-wedding-murders https://www.rationalistjudaism.com/p/mazeltov-murder-tonight

or questioning daas Fauci. https://www.rationalistjudaism.com/p/lovely-people-who-contribute-to-deaths

Alas, it turned out to be a rather benign analysis of what to make of the comments on Kikar Shaboss from a bunch of charedi commenters with irritating handles like מתי מבני ברק or נורמאלי who agree with Hapeles and Yated calling someone *else* a murderer. Oh well.

(To be clear, I happen to be vaccinated against Covid. I'm still alive, and am pretty sure I would be equally alive without the vaccine. I'm very much NOT interested in getting into a vaccine debate here.)

Expand full comment
195 more comments...

No posts