127 Comments
User's avatar
Joshua Karpoff's avatar

Even my second grader knows that Yaacov did three things to prepare to meet Eisav, at the start of Parshat Vayeshev: One was prayer, one was placate with gifts, and one was preparing for physical battle.

Dovid Hamelech was renown for both Torah learning and military prowess.

The generations of Moshe and Joshua had to be righteous and pray, but they also had to actually fight to conquer the land.

The Torah lists explicitly who was exempt from fighting, and it wasn’t those who learn Torah.

It does however exempt cowards from fighting.

David Ilan's avatar

Exactly let them at least be honest and admit they are cowards

Gdalya's avatar

Yaakov's preparation for physical battle was to divide the camps into two. That's all.

Ephraim's avatar

He prepared for physical battle. All you're doing is to provide your description of his preparation for physical battle. Nothing you write negates JK's point. (But see also the Ramban's citation of קהלת רבה. See also משכיל לדוד.)

Gdalya's avatar

No. I'm showing that the preparation for battle was not a preparation for natural battle. He split the camp, and that's all. And with that strategy (pathetic by any natural standards) Yaakov Avinu traveled TOWARD Esav and not away from him.

But you can't look at the whole picture at once because it will contradict your non-Jewish narrative of Jewish history.

Janon3's avatar

רוֹמְמ֣וֹת אֵ֭ל בִּגְרוֹנָ֑ם וְחֶ֖רֶב פִּיפִיּ֣וֹת בְּיָדָֽם

With paeans to God in their throats

And two-edged swords in their hands

Psalm 149:6

The psalmist begs to differ.

Ephraim's avatar

Gdalya sez: "Yaakov's preparation for physical battle... "

Gdalya sez: "..The preparation for battle was not a preparation for natural battle..."

" And with that strategy (pathetic by any natural standards) "

See משכיל לדוד:

לפי שכיון ששמע שעשו בא לערוך מלחמה נגדו היה מתיירא מברכת אביו והידים ידי עשו שאם יעשה ינצח ומכח זה מה עשה חלק הכל לשני מחנות ואמר בודאי והיה המחנה הנשאר לפליטה שהרי אני אלחם עמו להציל המחנה הראשון ואם הוא יתגבר מכח ברכת יצחק והידים ידי עשו אז בהכרח צריך שיתקיים ג״כ על המחנה האחר

Commentator 10952's avatar

According to the Cult Education Institute, there are specific warning signs to look out for when considering whether a group might be a cult. Cults are characterized by:

Absolute authoritarianism without accountability

Zero tolerance for criticism or questions

Lack of meaningful financial disclosure regarding budget

Unreasonable fears about the outside world that often involve evil conspiracies and persecutions

A belief that former followers are always wrong for leaving and there is never a legitimate reason for anyone else to leave

Abuse of members

Records, books, articles, or programs documenting the abuses of the leader or group

Followers feeling they are never able to be “good enough”

A belief that the leader is right at all times

A belief that the leader is the exclusive means of knowing “truth” or giving validation

Ephraim's avatar

I don't think any cult expert would agree with you.

Commentator 10952's avatar

I cannot speak to the expertise of the Cult Education Institute, but the above was cut and pasted from their website, with no modification. As for its applicability to the case at hand, feel free to judge for yourself.

Ephraim's avatar

" As for its applicability to the case at hand, feel free to judge for yourself. "

It's not applicable. There are cults in the Charedi world. But the Charedi world is not a cult.

You should do more than read a check list. Read up on victims of real cults.

Steven Katz's avatar

It's disturbing that they won't participate in Israeli life and defense, won';t recognize the gov't construct, but want the gov't (that they don't accept) to give them handouts. And worst (in my mind) is the lying and deception. To me, if you lie to or deceive me, I may never be able to trust you again, and if I can, when.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 11, 2025
Comment deleted
Steven Katz's avatar

And just how, in your mind, do you figure that this is Bibi's fault? You sound like many of the sufferers of Trump Derangement Syndrone who ERRONEOUSLY constructed false scenarios to blame everyone, especially Trump, for the follies and crimes of the leftists/socialists.

David Ohsie's avatar

People act rational when it is in their interests to do so. It is the politics driving them to these silly statements, not their embrace of Rav Chaim Volozhiner. All religion is irrational at some level. I think that you have the causality reversed here.

Nachum's avatar

One thing that struck me is something that is pointed out below as well: I don't think anyone- Right, Left, whatever- has assumed that the fall of Assad is a certain unalloyed good. Obviously Assad is a monster and Syria was a threat and we're better off without them, not to mention what this says about the whole Iran axis. But to start proclaiming this as the hand of God- whoops, the work of charedi yeshiva students- before we even know how it will pan out? The new guy in charge is a child-murderer, for God's sake. Israel isn't pulling out of the Syrian side of the border anytime soon, and a good thing too. But this genius knows everything ahead of time.

Refoel Zev's avatar

Your third comment is ridiculous. Those claiming Torah is defeating our enemies are involving Hashem in the picture much more than you ever do with all your talk of physical hishtadlus. Your whole theology is that Hashem isn't really in the picture, rather he lets us take things in our hands, whereas the Charedim believe that Hashem runs everything and responds based on our actions.

ChanaRachel's avatar

I see Dati communities very busy with fighting and with prayer (extra tehillim, avinu malkeinu, prayers for the hostages, for wounded soldiers). How do you see us leaving Hashem out of the picture?

It is only in (?many ?most) Haredi shuls and communities that the war is virtually ignored, both in terms of fighting and prayer. I don't know how that shows a greater acknowledgement of G-d.

Refoel Zev's avatar

I have no problem with Dati communities. My problem is with Slifkin's hypocritical approach

Uriah’s Wife's avatar

@Refoel Zev,

Hashem controls everything?

He must have had some serious issues with Los Angeles, Pacific Palisades and southern Calif. — almost as much as he had with Sodom and Gemorrah. I think Angelinos have reported pillars of salt mysteriously popping up in the vicinity of Pico Blvd.

And don’t get me started on Iceland! All those volcanos threatening to incinerate Rejkjevic. What does he have against Iceland?

Refoel Zev's avatar

I'm sorry but I thought this was an Orthodox forum. We don't believe in a vengeful deity who throws lightning bolts at those who anger Him. That doesn't preclude controlling nature and determining who lives and who dies (see Unesaneh Tokef)

Uriah’s Wife's avatar

@Refoel Zev,

You don’t believe in a vengeful deity. TANACH is replete with Hashem’s promise of vengeance if his commands and prohibitions aren’t adhered to, from the smallest to the largest transgression. Sodom & Gemorrah and Noach’s deluge wasn’t Hashem’s vengeance? Those are very funny Havdallah Besomim that you’re smoking.

California and Iceland must have sinned exceedingly. I wonder what they did?

Ephraim's avatar

"Those claiming Torah is defeating our enemies are involving Hashem in the picture much more than you ever do with all your talk of physical hishtadlus."

This claim is unclear. Are you comparing "those claiming Torah.." to "talk of physical hishtadlus"? Or Torah study and actual (not talking) "physical hishtadlus"?

Refoel Zev's avatar

I'm comparing the approach of the Charedim vs. what Slifkin believes to be the only proper approach.

Ephraim's avatar

"The Rosh Yeshiva quotes a lone aggadic teaching about Yaakov’s “sword and bow” referring to his wisdom and prayers. He takes this view as literal and definitive, extrapolates from it that military action never has any genuine significance. "

It's more than a lone aggada, it's Onkelos.

In any case, I don't think the פשט is that יעקב never took up arms.

David Zalkin's avatar

It actually doesn't appear in many old manuscripts of Onkelos.

David Ilan's avatar

Uncle Lewis’ is actually a compendium of translators and commentators. So you can’t really say with accuracy who’s opinion any particular statement it.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 11, 2025
Comment deleted
David Ilan's avatar

Nope. I did it on purpose…as per schlock rock

Ephraim's avatar

"without the IDF even having to make a pretense of doing anything."

"Third, as even some in the yeshiva world realized with shock, there is a striking downplaying of God. It’s all about the “power” of learning Torah, with barely a mention of Hashem. Torah simply becomes another type of weapon, a manifestation of “kochi v’otzem yadi.”

From דרש משה:

שדורו של דוד המלך שהיה דור צדיק והאמין בה', לכן יכל דוד לבקש מה' לנצח במלחמה בדרך הטבע משום ש"גם אם ילחם עמהם בנשק וכל עניני המלחמה וישיגם וינצחם, ידעו כל ישראל כי השי"ת עשה הישועה, אבל אסא בדורו שלא היו כל כך בעלי בטחון היה ירא שאם יעשה מלחמה דהיינו שירדוף וישיגם וינצחם יאמרו ח"ו שכחם עשה זה, לכן בקש מהשי"ת שהוא רק ירדוף ויעשה נס שיפלו חללים אף קודם שהשיגם, ויהושפט שהיה חושש מדורו שנתקטן באמונה אמר שגם לרדוף הוא ירא שמא יאמרו שהם נצחו מעצמם, ולכן התפלל שהקב"ה יכה והוא רק יאמר שירה, וחזקיה ירא גם לומר שירה שמא ח"ו יאמרו שזה עזר מעין סגולה, ולכן אמר שאין בו כח אף לומר שירה.."

So what kind of generation is ours?

James Nicholson's avatar

I think I read something similar in a Zohar once. Not that surprising, considering Ramchal's sources.

Ephraim's avatar

To clarify דרש משה is by R. Moshe Feinstein.

James Nicholson's avatar

Oh. Still probably not a coincidence.

Gdalya's avatar

"The Rosh Yeshiva quotes a lone aggadic teaching..."

Just pointing out, it's not a lone teaching. Yaakov's "preparation for war" (when Esav was approaching) that everybody likes to quote was nothing more than splitting the camp into two. And even that was not exactly what you think... but let's stick with the first point, he didn't exactly "prepare for war" even though that is what was said. There are more. But whatever.

Natan Slifkin's avatar

The Torah does not describe Yaakov preparing for fighting. Eisav had hundreds of men, there wouldn't have been a point. In fact this further disproves the charedi approach, because if numbers don't matter, why didn't Yaakov prepare for actual fighting? After all, that's certainly what the Bnei Yisrael did in every situation.

Gdalya's avatar

Not in every situation. And even in the situations in which they did, many times they did so in ways that no natural army would (e.g., Gidon). You always ignore this. And when someone mentions it, you try to slither out of it.

Natan Slifkin's avatar

So we have endless situations where the Bnie Yisrael actually physically fought, and a few cases of miracles. And you think that today we should follow the cases of miracles?

Gdalya's avatar

We should fight like a Jewish army. Start by sending away from the battle field every tamme keri, and also every soldier who has ANY aveyra (ast least as minor as talking between putting on hand and head tefillin let alone kfirah, chilul Shabbos, b'ilas nidah and other znus etc.). THAT is how the Torah says a Jewish army should fight.

Then see how many soldiers you have left.

(Of course, you'll come back with: "well then let the Charedim fight". But you'll be slithering away from the point, which is that the IDF is NOT a Jewish army.)

Ephraim's avatar

Gidon received a prophecy. We received something greater that prophecy - a Torah obligation to engage in a מלחמת מצוה.

Gdalya's avatar

You're joking. Right?

I'm going to listen to YOU explaining what the Torah wants us to do in a given situations instead of listening to people far greater than you in Torah and Yiras Shomayim and who have spent their entire lives immersed in Torah?

Ephraim's avatar

So you found a distinction between Yaakov and us and therefore we can't learn anything from Yaakov. That's modernishe reform talk.

It's not the difference that should interest you, it's the צד השוה. He prepared for war, and so should we.

"was nothing more than splitting the camp into two."

But enough about Ponevezh.

Gdalya's avatar

Don't be obtuse. You and Slifkin and co. do this all the time.

You say, well that's just one example (in fact, Slifkin did that in this very article referencing a "lone aggadic teaching" which is not so lone). The implication being that if there were more, then I would have a point. Then when I bring more and more and more examples, and also Torah directives that show that this is how Jews are instructed to fight a battle, then you all stammer and slither and start to do gymnastics to try and get out of it.

When I show (with mareh mkomos) that the State of Israel and the IDF way is not the way Jews are supposed to act in galus, you refer to the Tanach. So then I show that what is in Tanach is also not the way the state and the IDF is acting, and then you say it's a lone source. And then I bring lot's of sources. And you slither out of it with your invented pshetlach that have no source and contradict Chazal's explanations.

But you won't hear any of this. It will all go right over your head. I'm writing this in case I can prevent someone else from being perverted by your rhetoric.

Natan Slifkin's avatar

The only example you brought was the exception that proves the rule. The case of Gideon is exceptional.

Gdalya's avatar

You should really respect your readers more. Apparently you think they don't know much.

I've brought many examples in the comments section of many of your posts. You know that. If you want to ignore that, its your choice to be dishonest about it.

Ephraim's avatar

"Then when I bring more and more and more examples"

No. You brought more and more counter-examples.

Gdalya's avatar

You can say what you want. You've been dishonest in enough comments and responses to me

as for example here: https://open.substack.com/pub/rationalistjudaism/p/when-yeshivos-crushed-syria?r=2ce601&utm_campaign=comment-list-share-cta&utm_medium=web&comments=true&commentId=85966057

where I replied with this: https://open.substack.com/pub/rationalistjudaism/p/when-yeshivos-crushed-syria?r=2ce601&utm_campaign=comment-list-share-cta&utm_medium=web&comments=true&commentId=85980099

that I'm not even going to reply to this. they were good examples and you can misleadingly rename them whatever you want. In the article Slifkin even admitted to one which he called a "lone" example. But there are plenty of others which I have brought numerous times.

And in either case, since the destruction of the first Temple, we have never taken up arms without permission of the goyim unless it was to defend our right to keep the Torah. Another thing that you have not answered.

Except of course Bar Kochva. But to that we have R' S"R Hirsch to explain: "... when, during the reign of Hadrian, the uprising led by Bar Kochba proved a disastrous error, it became essential that the Jewish people be reminded for all times that Israel must never again attempt to restore its national independence by its own power; it is to entrust its future as a nation solely to Divine providence."

Efraim's avatar

While a religious Jew diligently fulfills all the commandments as prescribed by Jewish law, as found in texts such as the Shulchan Aruch and the Rambam, a Christian follows a different path, choosing to disregard Jewish law and instead adhere to the teachings of a prophet. On this divergence in approach "Rabbi Yoḥanan said: From the day that the Temple was destroyed, prophecy was taken from the prophets and given to imbeciles and children" (B. Bava Batra, 12 b).

Ezra Brand's avatar

What are you implying? Who in this discussion believes in prophecies of imbeciles?

Jew Well's avatar

Fourth, the downfall of Assad, while wonderful for the people he oppressed, is probably not such a positive development for Israel's security to begin with.

YidPoshut's avatar

If Syria ends up aligned with turkey it's a disaster the US won't be able to help with

Janon3's avatar

That's why you have "big weapons", in order that the enemy fears you. But if they know you fight soft no matter what, then it happens what it happens.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 10, 2025
Comment deleted
David Fass's avatar

"It is hard to imagine it being worse" sounds a bit like famous last words...

Nachum's avatar

The definition of a Jewish optimist: "It couldn't get worse."

Ephraim's avatar

"it is hard to imagine any of the rebel groups being worse."

Normal people like you don't have that kind of imagination. But basically a pragmatic non-fanatic murderer has been replace by a pragmatic fanatic who hasn't started mass murdering yet. All honeymoons must come to an end.

It reminds me of the (fictional) words of Henry VIII: "Six wives, and the best of them's the worst."

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 12, 2025
Comment deleted
Nachum's avatar

"If Hitler invaded Hell, I would make at least a favourable reference of the Devil in the House of Commons."

David Ohsie's avatar

"And given that the Assad regime was the single most murderous regime in the world today, propped up by the second worst, it is hard to imagine any of the rebel groups being worse."

Two big problems with this. Islamist regimes are quite oppressive to those who don't hew to the religion. Women's rights eliminated. You may simply end up trading one kind of oppression for another.

The bigger issue, is that Assad's Syria, like the regimes in Egypt and Jordan, really have no beef with Israel remaining as a sovereign country. Syria wanted the Golan back and maybe cared a little about the Palestinian cause and then got involved with Hezbollah to remain propped up. Israel would have been much better off if there had never been a Syrian civil war.

The new regime is Islamist which means that Israel's existence is something that should not be in their worldview. It is the difference between Morsi and el-Sisi. Morsi had more popular support, but as an Islamist, he was headed to greater and greater conflicts with Israel. el-Sisi is a strongman, but he is fundamentally reconciled to peace and co-existence with Israel.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jan 12, 2025
Comment deleted
David Ohsie's avatar

Hezbollah was Assad's vehicle for remaining in power and he was Hezbollah and Iran's pawn because he needed them to stay in power. No civil war and Hezbollah would not have been in Syria like that at all. You are just wrong about this and about the Islamist threat. Also, you are conflating Islam the religion with Islamist movements like the Muslim Brotherhood, Hamas, and HTS almost certainly is. No doubt Islam itself is not in conflict with the existence of Israel. Just as Judaism is not inherently in conflict with Palestinian rights even though the current version of political Religious Zionism currently in power in Israel is.

I agree that the side effect of removing Assad was lessening Hezbollah and Iran (a different set of Islamist) influence in Syria.

Shaul's avatar

Houston, we have a problem. The statements made by this rabbi, claiming that yeshiva students are the ultimate winners who defeat terrorists and terror-sponsoring states, are rooted in the Talmud. While rabbinical Judaism, based on the Talmud and midrashim, differs significantly from the Mosaic religion, it emerged in the Diaspora and is filled with mystical beliefs, exaggerated claims, and simplistic proverbs often regarded as divine promises.

When reality contradicts the Talmud, especially in areas like medicine, the haredim prioritize reality, seeking out the best doctors and treatments. However, when reality aligns with the Talmud (as in the current war, where others fight for them), they attribute the IDF success to their Torah study.

Oakeshott's avatar

"Third, as even some in the yeshiva world realized with shock, there is a striking downplaying of God. It’s all about the “power” of learning Torah, with barely a mention of Hashem."

The helplessness bred by Kabbalistic "Torah super power" determinism is no better better the helplessness that results from scientific determinism.

Uriah’s Wife's avatar

@Weaver,

@Weaver

“helplessness that results from scientific determinism”

Scientific determinism has not resulted in any helplessness on my part nor has resulted In overwhelming incapacity of clear methodical scientific discipline. Indeed, scientific determinism hasn’t been too keen a scientific notion. So, what are you talking about?

David Ohsie's avatar

Can you explain further? Even if physics is deterministic in principle, in practice, it is not because none of us are Laplace’s demon. And the Born rule means the future is not deterministic even in principle.

Oakeshott's avatar

I meant mainly the scientific determinism (such as it is) of the science vs religion free-will debates. If scientific determinism bothers people, mystical Torah-power determinism is little better. Just the mechanism is different.

David Fass's avatar

"a religious worldview which is illogical, foolish, anti-traditional, and veering on idolatry. "

Um, well, yes, their view might be more illogical and foolish that some other worldviews, but consider where you're starting from. If you start from a position of believing crazy things without any evidence and building these up into metaphysical truths that cannot be questioned, as pretty much every religious body of thought does, then you really can't be surprised that people end up with illogical and foolish ideas. That's exactly what they started with. If you want to say to them, "Listen, let's be rational, let's evaluate the evidence" you're going to have to take more than a few steps back, I'm afraid.

Natan Slifkin's avatar

Interesting post but I disagree with your using the term "Modern Orthodox" to describe the non-charedi position.

Daas Yochid's avatar

What term would you use?

Eli Turkel's avatar

mattisyahu died very early in the war. His sons are described very clearly in sefer makkabim as physical leaders of the war and of couse al hanissim talks about the wars

YidPoshut's avatar

Al hanisim was written in the late geonic period

David Ohsie's avatar

Whether or not it is historically accurate, it certainly represents a traditional Jewish worldview.