Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Garvin's avatar

Previous posts had 262 and 230 mostly-negative comments; this one had eight (8) comments, and yet you claim it was "well-received".

The post was actually offensive, an attempt to stir up machlokes. You were smart to hide it behind a pay wall, because you know darn well you would have been called out for it, and rightfully so.

Expand full comment
Leib Shachar's avatar

I've been very involved in the sugya of the amma, the shortest legitimate size I know of is 17.5 inches, or 44.5 cm, presented in ספר מידות ושיעורי תורה by Rabbi Chaim Benish, based on both archeology and the Rambam. Are you looking for smaller than that?

(As far as your first point, I always was of the impression that it would be more effective with the tone of your last article.)

Expand full comment
20 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?