Rationalist Judaism

Share this post

"They Could Say It, We Cannot"

www.rationalistjudaism.com

"They Could Say It, We Cannot"

Natan Slifkin
Jul 30, 2010
Share this post

"They Could Say It, We Cannot"

www.rationalistjudaism.com

With everything that I write, there are always people expressing their comments and their beliefs as to how true/unacceptable it is. I was therefore amazed that I didn't get a single piece of feedback on my article in Hakirah “They Could Say It, We Cannot”: Defining the Charge of Heresy. It dealt with an incredibly important and provocative topic that lies at the heart of the Torah-science controversies of the last few years: the very definition of heresy. It's now freely available for download; click here. Since writing the article, I have been working further on the tricky topic of defining heresy; I gave a lecture on this topic recently in LA and I plan to write a full treatment of it. Meanwhile, here's a fascinating quote from Prof. Haym Soloveitchik. He raises the question of why Rambam listed belief in the preeminence of Moshe's prophecy as a fundamental; would anyone really care if someone believed that, say, Yechezkel was his equal? He answers as follows:

...An ikkar does not arise from the fact that its negation is false, but from the fact that its negation undermines the Jewish system of belief. That Moses’ prophecy was of a different order than that of other prophets is an explicit verse in the Torah (Numbers 12:7); [but] it was a specific historic context, its denial by Islam, that turned this verse from a religious dictum into an ikkar. A belief is an ikkar when its content is what differentiates Judaism from the surrounding credal system.
(“Two Notes on the Commentary on the Torah of R. Yehudah he-Hasid,” p. 244)

Share this post

"They Could Say It, We Cannot"

www.rationalistjudaism.com
Previous
Next
Comments
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2023 Natan Slifkin
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
Substack is the home for great writing