33 Comments
User's avatar
LOL's avatar

That's what happens when you appoint 18-year-old girls as army commanders!

Natan Slifkin's avatar

19. She spent a year in Midrasha.

Scott Smith's avatar

Anything in the instruction of new recruits about the Damascus blood libel and other 19th century massacres of the Jewish community of the Levant? The problem with basing the case for Israel on what Europe did to the Jews is that nothing that Europe did can counter the response, "yes Europe did nasty things to the Jews, but why should the 'innocent' Palestinians pay the price?" Calling attention to what Islam did to the Jews, particularly in the Levant, demonstrates that the Palestinians are not so innocent.

Dovid Dov's avatar

Very amusing tale. I was less amused by "surprised my wife and I".

Rational Traditionalist's avatar

I wonder how many kids are noled in that ambatya

Daas Yochid's avatar

This is funny.

Is your daughter ok with this being written? She may find it embarrassing.

Yakov's avatar

I doubt that any man would think that אמבטיה means מקלחת or אמבטיה literally. It takes a woman to lead 15 soldiers to hide in shower stalls. This isn't very funny.

Yoni2's avatar

It’s not often you get to see a self refuting argument. Or are you a woman?

Yakov's avatar

You have a point, lol. What idiot would let a 19 year old 'comander' lead him to hide in the shower stalls? I'm surprised that all 15 soldiers followed her. Whatever she teaches them, it's not critical and rational thinking.

Yoni2's avatar

More to the point, what idiot would reply to such an obviously stupid comment! (That's a self confirming argument for anyone interested)

Yakov's avatar

Good critical and rational thinking! Was a pleasure hearing from you.

Building Worlds's avatar

Glad you acknowledge that..... דרכו של איש לעשות מלחמה ולא אשה 

Editor's avatar

Gosh why would you embarrass her publicly in reporting this mishap to your readership?? It wasn't bad enough for her the first time to be a laughingstock?

Natan Slifkin's avatar

She was very happy for me to post it, she has an excellent sense of humor.

Joe Berry's avatar

A truly enjoyable posting. I'm reminded about when I was drafted into the IDF when I was 40 years old!! This was, of course, back in the 80s when we did miluim until age 55. We were all olim from many different countries. I remember our mifaked, an 18 to 20 year old officer originally from France. He had difficulties dealing with all of us "older" folks while we had difficulty taking that young commander seriously. I definitely understand why your daughter isn't addressed by her name.

Building Worlds's avatar

Waiting for a response to the article in Mispacha Magazine by it's publisher Eli Paley on the topic of Judicial reform.

https://mishpacha.com/time-for-dialogue/

Bigbartha's avatar

Thanks Inquire for sharing! I just learned from Mr. Paley that antipathy towards Chareidim is engendered by left-wing politicians and has little-to-nothing to do with the actions of Chareidim themselves, including due to COVID...

"Every fire needs fuel, and this one is no exception. The fears of the secular public have been fed by years of obsessive incitement and libel by any number of radical elements, including opposition leader Yair Lapid and Yisrael Beiteinu chairman Avigdor Lieberman. They and their allies have gained huge political capital by presenting the chareidim as agents of chaos in Israel society, as a cadre of primitive and backward parasites who pose a deep threat to the secular public.

...

The steady flow of incitement is the reason why secular Israel’s hostility toward the chareidi sector has grown, even as the country has become more Westernized and more liberal. These sentiments were widely manifested during the Covid crisis, when secular writers and influencers publicly fingered chareidim as “disease vectors.”"

Bigbartha's avatar

Query whether meaningful dialogue can be had where one side isn't willing to recognize its shortcomings and rake personal responsibility for its actions.

Nate's avatar

I think you and your readership will get a kick out of the following https://www.theyeshivaworld.com/?p=2172902

Todd Ellner's avatar

Starting off in a command position? She has a bright future!

User's avatar
Comment removed
Mar 13, 2023
Comment removed
Todd Ellner's avatar

What it means is they've tapped her as having the qualities that would make a good senior noncom or officer some day. And that's nothing to sneer at even if the initial assignment isn't a sexy one like fighter pilot

Natan Slifkin's avatar

They asked her to join officer training but she declined.

LES AYM's avatar

Why is she not allowed to let them know that she knows English fluently and why are they not allowed to know her name?

Natan Slifkin's avatar

If they know she knows English, they will speak to her in English and not learn Hebrew.

They are not allowed to know her name because of "distance".

Gidon Ariel's avatar

There is nothing as funny as idf service. Nothing.

Avraham's avatar

Have a niece dentist who just did basic training to work as an army dentist. Basic training is as full of strange tales as fleas on a dog's back.

Yisrael Bronstein's avatar

What is the title of the sefer with the tank?

Just Curious's avatar

It appears to be “Kitzur Torat Hamachaneh Hashalem”.