11 Comments
User's avatar
K.J. Smith's avatar

Dr. Gerald Schroeder has written that for apes to have split into an evolutionary direction from humans is mathematically impossible.

There is not enough time for a group of apes to develop through random mutations that “select” for a non purposeful outcome in any group into a new species.This happens only in micro-evolution where a preordained genetic predisposition can result in an epigenetic variance.

This is seen in the starving North Korean population whose height is five inches shorter than the pre Korean War equality in height.It is also seen today,especially in the quick growth in under twenty children.It is caused by ingredients that preserve food,especially cereals,bread,and other ready to eat nutrients tocopherals,vitamin E super antioxident,B vitamins as pyridoxal((B-6 type),that guards against acrylamides,glycation and excess oxidative stress in the cellular integrity of growing and maturing.

The idea of a herd of animals that cannot grow too large in numbers for lack of food availability in the distant past to change into something different is ludicrous.They are prey animals and using a selective pressure to evolve into another is not seen in nature.

You give an analogy of morphological similarity of a whale and bat is nonsense.The Harvard evolutionary biologist,Stephen Jay Gould discarded gradual evolution because he saw the lack of any change since the Cambrian era explosion of single cell life in the fossil record 530 million years ago to advanced life without any evidence of any transitional forms that must have lived in order to evolve.He invented the term “punctuated equilibrium” to self approve of very long time periods of no change to rapid change.

His counterpart at Harvard,as well as the director of the American Museum of Narural History,Erwin Mayr,developed another theory.The synthetic theory combined Darwinian random mutations combined with Mendelian.Gregor Mendel was a monk who developed pea plants as a hobby and became a forerunner in genetic theory.He saw successive generations of plants becoming tall and short from one to the next.The genetic predisposition was supposedly similar in all life.It showed variety in genetics that was not uniform.This was presumed by evolutionists to be advancing in an evolutionary sense and later used by Mayr to combine random mutations and genetic variability to believe in useful species change.

The fallacy is that small populations that are isolated can change.This is false insofar as the Galapagos finches with larger beaks on different islands and larger tortoises simply showed evolution.That false assumption was that each surviving creature was permanent.Not so.But as Mendel had shown only variation in a population not a permanent short term change,surely not by mutations that are mostly neutral and otherwise deleterious.The finches and tortoises returned to baseline size as health after illness returns to genetic baseline.

Another idea is gradual evolution in the geologic column that the founder of paleontology and comparative anatomy,the French scientist Georges Cuvier,b.1769-d.1832.He surmized that the rock layer stratigraphy showed only complete fossils,never new speciation,in advanced morphology.

He saw it as new but different creatures that were formed after catastrophic events.He saw it as new formation creation from one time period to the next.

There were five distinct major catastrophes on the earth in history.The Torah shows six periods of time called days that bookends the five major catastrophes.One wiped out dinosaurs.Others later animals.The most recent,70,000 years ago,caused near collapse in all life forms after the Toba,Indonesia volcanic destruction.One,900,000 years ago,through genetically derived DNA analysis from eastern populations,showed that the early archaic human,homo erectus,was reduced to less than 1000 individuals.

Homoerectus is one of about six or perhaps many more separate archaic humans living separately as well as contemporaneously.Some interbred,including eastern Neanderthal with Denisovan(only in eastern populations),and western Neanderthal with Homoerectus in Asia.Western Neanderthal interbred with cromagon,who only appeared from 40,000 years ago in Europe.Their hybrid remains were discovered in the Balkans and Skhul and qafzeh caves in Israel.Neanderthal disappeared as a separate archaic human at around that time.No Neanderthal DNA is in Africa except from the return of mixed genetic people only from two thousand years ago.

Africa has large genetic diversity as well as ghost DNA from ancient archaic humans from hundreds of thousands of years ago.One small such living group from Western Africa,has a haplogroup labeled A000,to denote its distinct antiquity.Another American from generations ago in South Carolina was also found to have the A000 haplotype.

The Torah speaks of the formation not creation of the Adam from the earth.The first law of thermodynamics,is that matter/energy cannot be created or destroyed.

The second law of thermodynamics is that all matter/energy becomes disordered.Founded by Rudolf Clausius,B.1822,-D.1888,a physicist and mathematician,showed that this disorder always occurs but the results are often recycled in nature as fertilizer brings brings about new food sources and water dissipates when heated but still exists as later rain or clouds or glaciers.

The Einstein formula of E=MC2 showed that matter and energy are equivalent and includes the C,that light squared became the law of special relativity.

These fundamental laws do not allow changes,only variation within a created domain.As Immanuel Velikovsky revealed in his ten years of research at Columbia university from 1940-1950,that the catastrophic events that have caused 99.9% of all life that has ever existed is now extinct.It is a devolution not evolution.His books,especially “Earth in Upheaval”,is a remarkable treatise in geologic history as Cuvier previously discovered.He was 17 years younger than Einstein,but lived nearby in Princeton,,New Jersey where many great physicists also lived including Feynman and Von Neuman amongst others at different times.Velikovsky became friendly with Einstein and had conversations regularly.The Velikovsky book,“Worlds in Collision”,was found open on the desk of Einstein when he was found after he was niftar.

Natan Slifkin's avatar

Gould did not reject common ancestry. Nor does any other scientist except fundamentalist Christians. Schroeder is not a biologist, but I wonder if he really does reject the idea that the bad backs and wisdom teeth we suffer from are due to our animal origins.

Talking Tachlis's avatar

R' Slifkin, if I may ask, do you truly believe that man evolved from ape/monkey, or some other animal? Interested to know where you stand on this. Thanks.

Talking Tachlis's avatar

Appreciate the prompt response.

I know I should probably buy your book to read up on how you came to this conclusion, but per the referenced article in your reply, I hope your whole belief system on evolution isn't based on lower back pain. 😁

Natan Slifkin's avatar

Lol, no!

Ever wonder why whales have to come to the surface to breath, instead of having gills like fish?

Talking Tachlis's avatar

Lol, not really. But assuming it's due to evolution, I wouldn't automatically make the jump to man because of it.

Like I said, I probably need to read your book to get more information on everything.

Russell Gold's avatar

You might also note that, while religion focuses on correspondence of scripture to the world, science is focused on observations, and especially on using theory to predict future observations.

For example, if you saw a seed grow within seconds to a tree that, according to every observations you could make, including examine its bark and the rings of its trunk, appears to be 600 years old, is it an instantly created 600-year-old tree or actually a seconds-old tree that just looks really old? I would suggest that the scientific answer would be the former, while a religious answer would be the latter.

Reasonable Doubt's avatar

Why didn’t you quote the Malbim?

Reasonable Doubt's avatar

Malbim pashas bereishis. Guided evolution. Notes that order of maaseh bereishis is ascending in sophistication from elemental to simple vegetation to more sophisticated to successive stages of animal to human. Theorizes that He set in motion for each to evolve from its predecessor. He adds though, that each major tier (plant, animal, human) can only perform its more sophisticated functions because, at that stage in its evolution, God stepped in to implant the next level soul.

In his trademark style, he supports his read with a very methodical analysis of the text, focusing on order, repetitive and unusual phrasing, and the like.

Talking Tachlis's avatar

What does the Malbim say?