Discussion about this post

User's avatar
זכרון דברים's avatar

It's always the other guy that has to do Teshuva, isn't it funny how things work out?

Expand full comment
דוד™️'s avatar

I mostly agree with much of what you said. There is a crucial point that if people are being insensitive to each other, which often comes from personal devotion to their religion, that there is something terribly amiss. There needs to be emphasis on the community coming together.

That being said, there are two points to be made:

1. "Rabbi Yona Metzger no doubt sincerely believed that he was serving Hashem, even as he engaged in bribery, corruption, threatening others, and sexual harassment." What?? That was a really silly thing to say. I know very little about Yona Metzger but he has nothing to do with your point. Even if religious devotion can lead to selfishness, if we find bribery and corruption like you describe, that is *not* because of the religion, that is unequivocally *despite* it. Your point can be a really great point in more mild terms, such as how the focus on self improvement and personal connection to God can lead a person to be more selfish, but someone who is outwardly hurting others, that has nothing to do with the religion; it is a flaw of the man alone. (And to bring in Reb Elyashiv זצוק"ל - he obviously didn't know of these private matters or he would never had stood for them.) You took things unnecessarily far, and it kind of killed your whole message (especially when your whole point was to be less divisive).

2. More importantly - Judaism is indeed meant to improve people and better society - but not in a vacuum! We are supposed to - as a nation, as a whole - become better and more wholesome. But who are these people who are supposed to be bettering themsleves? We, the nation of Hashem. The nation which stands for HKBH and His will. The nation that devotes themselves to His Torah and Avoda. The people who say Shema and accept to follow God's will and commandments with every fiber of the their beings. In that context, we are supposed to do this *as a nation* and become better people and a better society. This context is very important. Religion can become a self promoting personal mission while it is supposed to be a collective undertaking. This public, national function then breeds kindness to the widows, aiding the wronged and learning to do good.

Simply being collectively 'good' without the religious, Godly mission behind it is just icing without the cake.

*What is Tisha B'Av actually about?* - It is the day that we devote to appreciating the loss of HKBH from our lives and how we *as a nation - together* work on our collective mission, bringing Him back into this dark, atheistic world. As such, we should all be zoche *together* to see HKBH join us here as we serve Him as a joined nation in the beis hamikdash, the finest community to be.

Expand full comment
256 more comments...

No posts