Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Tzirel Shaffren's avatar

I had no idea that there was a custom of a siren and standing in silence until we made Aliya some 20 years ago. I never thought that deeply about it, and instinctively stood and said Tehillim during the moment of silence and have been doing so ever since. I talk with Hashem and thank Him for this beautiful land, but remember all those who sacrificed to bring us to this place, this moment (and because I am who I am, I beg Him to send Mashiach so no more of us need to suffer). My underlying thought is that this is a moment of unity, where everyone in Israel is thinking about the same thing. This is a beautiful opportunity to turn to Hashem, for surely our unity resonates with Hashem. At the time of our first siren, and in fact, really until reading this article, I didn't think that there was a controversy or that my saying Tehillim during the siren could be offensive to some. I still don't believe there really is a controversy. I think that when the sirens sound, regardless of your beliefs, there is a moment where we all think about those who lost their lives in the building of this modern nation. Reactions to the siren might be different, but there is no doubt that the sound of it has the impact of turning your thoughts to its intended purpose. And in that way, and for those moments, we are a united people.

Expand full comment
Mikhail Olivson's avatar

Let those who stand silent continue that and let those who say Tehillim continue that. Both are expressing respect in their own manner.

Expand full comment
87 more comments...

No posts