It's really quite simple. Many academics, no matter how niche their field of study, overemphasize the importance of their field. And if they happen to be antisemitic, you'll the kind of crank balderdash produced by Hazrat.
Try this out, prompt your favorite chatbot with "____ as a pivotal factory in world history" and fill in the blank with anything.
Here are some results:
"While it might seem like a humble breakfast food or a simple kitchen staple today, yoghurt has played an surprisingly pivotal role in shaping world history. "
"the potato fundamentally altered global demographics, fueled the Industrial Revolution, and completely redrew the geopolitical map of Europe."
"hailstones have acted as nature’s ultimate geopolitical wild card—abruptly shattering military campaigns, triggering revolutions, and altering the line of royal successions."
" feathered caps and hats rewrote the maps of global trade, catalyzed the colonization of North America, and birthed the modern international environmental conservation movement."
"From the ancient tombs of Egypt to the height of the Cold War, dolls have consistently been weaponized, commodified, and utilized by adults to shape the course of human history."
" hedgehogs have spent centuries quietly orchestrating legal battles, driving classical manufacturing economies, and defining modern military and philosophical strategy."
I was so shocked by her words that I had to double-check if I was reading them correctly. As an Iranian, she should know that the Persian language is not Arabic. The real historic resistance lay in adapting the script: Persians added four unique letters for sounds that Arabic lacks, creating the Perso-Arabic alphabet. This modified script then spread across Central, South, and Southeast Asia, largely as a cultural footprint following Arab conquests.
>"And much more fundamentally, the Arabic language itself and culture originated in Arabia! It’s extraordinary that Hazrat presents Hebrew - a language that originated in the Land of Israel, and has been used by Jews ever since - as an example of European origins and foreignness to Palestine, rather than Arabic which actually originated outside of Palestine!"
Great point, something I only realized relatively recently. I think this point is underrated, and should be brought up more.
>>“Punctuation marks in Hebrew are relics of a brutal colonial system that is far from over… Language - including punctuation - is complicit in this process, paving the way for an artificial sense of unity among Jewish people from all over the globe, encouraging them to move to the land that already had people—a people made to suffer and bear the brunt of European anti-Semitism in the most horrendous ways for generations, causing bloody wars across the entire Middle Eastern region…”[...]
>Er, no, actually the people made to suffer and bear the brunt of European antisemitism in the most horrendous ways for generations were the Jews, who were massacred in the millions.
I agree completely with the thrust your entire post in your general, but I wonder if you're misreading this particular paragraph. I think it's a bit ambiguous, it might be parsed as (brackets mine): "a people [=Jews] made to suffer and bear the brunt of European anti-Semitism in the most horrendous ways for generations, [now] causing bloody wars across the entire Middle Eastern region…”
In general, anti-semites/anti-Zionists typically are happy to admit that Ashkenazi Jews were persecuted, but they claim that post-Holocaust, they're now (ostensibly) the persecuters.
1) In a similar vein, R’ Slifkin points out in his “Lions of Zion” that it’s rather rich that the folks who get all worked up about Israel’s ostensible “colonialism” don’t seem to mind the fact that the Hashemites of Saudi Arabia *actually* colonized Jordan.
2) Disturbing as it is, I am reasonably certain R’ Slifkin’s reading is the correct one. This lady writes “…encouraging them [Jews] to move to the land that already had people [i.e., native Arabs]—a people made to suffer and bear the brunt of European anti-Semitism…”
It’s clear at the first “people” and the second “people” in that (poorly constructed) sentence are referring the same people.
Unbelievable as it may seem, this lady actually has the chutzpah to transfer the “brunt of European anti-Semitism” from its actual victims (i.e., *its actual victims*) to the Arabs who have had to “suffer” the resultant Zionism.
I have not done any "homework" to confirm this but it appears to me that Arabic comes from a combination of Hebrew and Aramaic. Numbers in Arabic seem to be identical to those in Aramaic. And there are so many words in Arabic that are obviously identical to those in Hebrew if you only change the accent or pronunciation slightly.
Your strongest point is the double standard: European punctuation in Arabic counts as resistance, in Hebrew as colonialism. Same act, opposite verdict. That alone sinks her thesis. I'm less convinced by the cactus and the Jaffa orange. That argument accepts her premise, that where something comes from decides who belongs. It's the premise worth rejecting, not turning around. And the paragraphs on empty land and a population that only gained open a far more contested front than the dagesh.
I see endless Facebook posts naming all the human rights organizations calling Gaza a genocide. The Creative Community list of signatories to the letter refuting that claim is encouraging, but nearly everyone on it is Jewish and can justifiably be considered biased.
What I'd like to see is a list of neutral persons and organizations who also see that horrific as the situation is, it's not a genocide. It won't change the haters' minds, but they will have to concede its impartiality.
Thank you as always but her comments - not research- in her book about Jews and Israel are so ignorant and hateful I’m impressed you even bothered to comment on her stupidity at all
I have never learned Hebrew, but have heard it said that there is no punctuation in the language - that it just flows. If this is true, then surely her book is surely nonsense. What else has she got wrong?
It’s worth noting that, in addition to cantillation symbols, Hebrew has an extensive series of diacritical marks (“nikud”, commonly referred to as “vowels”, but literally meaning “punctuation”) that indicate how words are to be pronounced and various other grammatical details.
As Elliott Shevin pointed out, these were added to the classical Hebrew script by the Masoretes ~1,200 yrs ago.
I think that the only reason her book has gotten any "positive" attention is because of her 3 page antisemitic rant.
Has anyone asked why she doesn't know what she is talking about?
Possibly because she’s an imbecile?
It's really quite simple. Many academics, no matter how niche their field of study, overemphasize the importance of their field. And if they happen to be antisemitic, you'll the kind of crank balderdash produced by Hazrat.
Try this out, prompt your favorite chatbot with "____ as a pivotal factory in world history" and fill in the blank with anything.
Here are some results:
"While it might seem like a humble breakfast food or a simple kitchen staple today, yoghurt has played an surprisingly pivotal role in shaping world history. "
"the potato fundamentally altered global demographics, fueled the Industrial Revolution, and completely redrew the geopolitical map of Europe."
"hailstones have acted as nature’s ultimate geopolitical wild card—abruptly shattering military campaigns, triggering revolutions, and altering the line of royal successions."
" feathered caps and hats rewrote the maps of global trade, catalyzed the colonization of North America, and birthed the modern international environmental conservation movement."
"From the ancient tombs of Egypt to the height of the Cold War, dolls have consistently been weaponized, commodified, and utilized by adults to shape the course of human history."
" hedgehogs have spent centuries quietly orchestrating legal battles, driving classical manufacturing economies, and defining modern military and philosophical strategy."
Why not question marks¿
I was so shocked by her words that I had to double-check if I was reading them correctly. As an Iranian, she should know that the Persian language is not Arabic. The real historic resistance lay in adapting the script: Persians added four unique letters for sounds that Arabic lacks, creating the Perso-Arabic alphabet. This modified script then spread across Central, South, and Southeast Asia, largely as a cultural footprint following Arab conquests.
Where does she conflate the Persian language with Arabic?
great piece, as usual.
comments:
1)
>"And much more fundamentally, the Arabic language itself and culture originated in Arabia! It’s extraordinary that Hazrat presents Hebrew - a language that originated in the Land of Israel, and has been used by Jews ever since - as an example of European origins and foreignness to Palestine, rather than Arabic which actually originated outside of Palestine!"
Great point, something I only realized relatively recently. I think this point is underrated, and should be brought up more.
For more discussion, see Wikipedia's entry on Arabization: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arabization
2)
>>“Punctuation marks in Hebrew are relics of a brutal colonial system that is far from over… Language - including punctuation - is complicit in this process, paving the way for an artificial sense of unity among Jewish people from all over the globe, encouraging them to move to the land that already had people—a people made to suffer and bear the brunt of European anti-Semitism in the most horrendous ways for generations, causing bloody wars across the entire Middle Eastern region…”[...]
>Er, no, actually the people made to suffer and bear the brunt of European antisemitism in the most horrendous ways for generations were the Jews, who were massacred in the millions.
I agree completely with the thrust your entire post in your general, but I wonder if you're misreading this particular paragraph. I think it's a bit ambiguous, it might be parsed as (brackets mine): "a people [=Jews] made to suffer and bear the brunt of European anti-Semitism in the most horrendous ways for generations, [now] causing bloody wars across the entire Middle Eastern region…”
In general, anti-semites/anti-Zionists typically are happy to admit that Ashkenazi Jews were persecuted, but they claim that post-Holocaust, they're now (ostensibly) the persecuters.
BTW, on the topic of popular books on punctuation, I really enjoyed this book (and no antisemitism in it!): https://www.amazon.com/Shady-Characters-Punctuation-Symbols-Typographical-ebook/dp/B00CF2M96E/
1) In a similar vein, R’ Slifkin points out in his “Lions of Zion” that it’s rather rich that the folks who get all worked up about Israel’s ostensible “colonialism” don’t seem to mind the fact that the Hashemites of Saudi Arabia *actually* colonized Jordan.
2) Disturbing as it is, I am reasonably certain R’ Slifkin’s reading is the correct one. This lady writes “…encouraging them [Jews] to move to the land that already had people [i.e., native Arabs]—a people made to suffer and bear the brunt of European anti-Semitism…”
It’s clear at the first “people” and the second “people” in that (poorly constructed) sentence are referring the same people.
Unbelievable as it may seem, this lady actually has the chutzpah to transfer the “brunt of European anti-Semitism” from its actual victims (i.e., *its actual victims*) to the Arabs who have had to “suffer” the resultant Zionism.
I have not done any "homework" to confirm this but it appears to me that Arabic comes from a combination of Hebrew and Aramaic. Numbers in Arabic seem to be identical to those in Aramaic. And there are so many words in Arabic that are obviously identical to those in Hebrew if you only change the accent or pronunciation slightly.
They're all Semitic languages, descended from Proto-Semitic, so essentially "cousins"
Your strongest point is the double standard: European punctuation in Arabic counts as resistance, in Hebrew as colonialism. Same act, opposite verdict. That alone sinks her thesis. I'm less convinced by the cactus and the Jaffa orange. That argument accepts her premise, that where something comes from decides who belongs. It's the premise worth rejecting, not turning around. And the paragraphs on empty land and a population that only gained open a far more contested front than the dagesh.
To quote Charlie Brown, Good Grief! The antisemities never sleep and always come up with bizarre reasons to hate Jews.
I see endless Facebook posts naming all the human rights organizations calling Gaza a genocide. The Creative Community list of signatories to the letter refuting that claim is encouraging, but nearly everyone on it is Jewish and can justifiably be considered biased.
What I'd like to see is a list of neutral persons and organizations who also see that horrific as the situation is, it's not a genocide. It won't change the haters' minds, but they will have to concede its impartiality.
Thank you as always but her comments - not research- in her book about Jews and Israel are so ignorant and hateful I’m impressed you even bothered to comment on her stupidity at all
I have never learned Hebrew, but have heard it said that there is no punctuation in the language - that it just flows. If this is true, then surely her book is surely nonsense. What else has she got wrong?
There has been punctuation in Hebrew, in the form of cantillation symbols, since the ninth century, but it only appears in printed Bibles.
Yes. That's what I thought
Also, you should learn Hebrew! It’s great! 😁
I would love to do that!
It’s worth noting that, in addition to cantillation symbols, Hebrew has an extensive series of diacritical marks (“nikud”, commonly referred to as “vowels”, but literally meaning “punctuation”) that indicate how words are to be pronounced and various other grammatical details.
As Elliott Shevin pointed out, these were added to the classical Hebrew script by the Masoretes ~1,200 yrs ago.