410 Comments
User's avatar
Mark's avatar

Also worth noting the ugliness of the phrase "like a bullet in an Arab’s head". Like a bullet in a Hamas member's head, yes I'm in favor. But many Arabs (the exact proportion is irrelevant as long as it's more than zero) oppose Hamas, or else are children too young to have an opinion. They don't deserve a bullet in the head.

Avraham marcus's avatar

One can refer to an enemy nation in the collective when one is at war. There were nice Germans in dresden too.

Howard Schranz's avatar

Israeli is not at war with the "Arab nation."

Howard Schranz's avatar

Well, that better end some day, Vrumster. Since there r 1/2 billion "Arabs" in the world, as opposed to 16 M Jews, we had better find a way to make some permanent peace with them ASAP.

Charles Joseph's avatar

That’s nuts . We aren’t at war with any Arabs except the entities we are war with. So many Arab nations root for us. That’s just bigoted ugly talk

Eli B's avatar

Very wrong, but anyway

Michael's avatar

I agree. Hamas are Arabs, as other enemies of Israel (but not Iran, which is not an Arab country). But Israel also have good relations with some Arab countries, there are Israeli Arabs fighting in Gaza as soldiers of the Tzavah (like the druzim), Israeli Arabs were killed in October 7th, Israeli Arabs saved Jews during October 7th, Israeli Arabs are kept as hostages by Hamas. The reality is complex.

Daas Yochid's avatar

Because it's magical mystical metaphysical stuff. Hashem decides what to do with each tefillah and directs it in the right direction.

Natan Slifkin's avatar

You're not explaining why the story is funny.

Daas Yochid's avatar

It's funny because no one actually believes it works that way. Rather, tefillos enter the tefillos metasphere realm where they are directed by malachim to where they need to go. the bullets are a mashal, not how chareidim actually see reality.

(Note that this is not my understanding of tefillah, but merely the common litvish one. Breslov has an entirely different perception.)

Natan Slifkin's avatar

And yet we certainly direct tefillos for specific people!

shulman's avatar

is that your issue? one can daven for a specific thing, sure. but when this kid asked if he can target a specific arab he was thinking about the moshol very vividly so it was adorable

MK's avatar

True, and we also pray 3 times a day for all of Am Yisroel to be healed. Praying for individual sick people is something people do when they have an emotional connection with someone and they specifically want that person to be healed. Whereas it would be slightly odd to have a negative emotional connection with a specific terrorist he wanted killed. That's why it's a funny question. But I would agree if someone would, for whatever reason, have a negative emotional connection with a specific terrorist, he can absolutely pray for that one to be killed.

Anyway, I've noticed you're always evasive on your opinion on the effectiveness of prayer. Instead of playing "gotcha" and assuming hypocrisies, I think it would be more productive if you just came out and told us your opinion on it.

Daas Yochid's avatar

Its easier to believe tefillah can save a specific person (because we want to believe it) than harm.

Charles Joseph's avatar

Do you actually believe in anything larger than yourself?

Marty Bluke's avatar

Many of the rishonim especially the philosophic ones have a very difficult with tefila. They point out that one of the attributes of hashem is that he is unchanging so how can our tefilos change gods decisions? They work very hard on this question and the answer is not so simple. Nowadays most people ignore these questions but the questions are real. See http://ajewwithquestions.blogspot.com/2017/02/tefilladavening.html

shulman's avatar

what's the breslov perception, might i ask? reb nachman based his ideas on the zohar, and the zohar (in teruma?) is quite clear about these malachim and things...

Daas Yochid's avatar

Rebbe Nachman holds that tefilla, especially hisbodedus has a real actual effect. Not that it goes to the malachsphere, but with enough tefilla you will get what you want. (I've seen this in my own life). He doesn't like the apologetics of redirected tefillos. If it isn't working, just do more.

YL's avatar

what does breslov say?

Yosef Hirsh's avatar

You are not explaining how you can simultaneously bash chareidim for not davening and saying tehhilim for the IDF and then mocking the effectiveness of it.

Its all about hate for you.

Natan Slifkin's avatar

No, actually the explanation is very simple.

shulman's avatar

you think it doesn't work. but at least if they do they should use their supposed weapons?

Charles Joseph's avatar

Please consider that if so many people think you are off, you might be. People in your situation, obsessed with a woman, obsessed with fear of disease, obsessed in your case, with past slights, are always the last to know it. You are immensely talented, Are you absolutely certain that you are focusing this God given gift on productive activity? If you are certain, does that make you right? Cromwell put it best: "I beseech you, in the bowels of Christ, to think it possible you may be mistaken.."

Yosef Hirsh's avatar

I expect i will get banned for pointing out this contradiction...so so long folks.

Natan Slifkin's avatar

No, but I want to challenge you to figure out the explanation, because it's really, really straightforward.

Charles Joseph's avatar

To his credit I dont think he bans anyone.

Mark's avatar

I have a feeling Hashem doesn't do anything with tefilot that are offered with the flippant attitude that appears here.

shulman's avatar

that's super clear. chazal say that Hashem's response actually is based on the person's connection with the tefila. it's a relationship between us and Him and when we go and meet Him, He comes and greets us as per our efforts. so if we have been doing the right things and learning and being nice to people, the tefilos will be more accepted. (actually, come to think of it, one maareh makom is in this past week's parsha where yaakov's tefilos were accepted right away because he had just spent 14 years perfectly connected to his avodas Hashem)

shulman's avatar

Couldn't have said it better

Natan Slifkin's avatar

You're not explaining why the story is funny.

shulman's avatar

it's funny because it's cute. it's a moshol of course, even when expressed to adults. we all get how bullets are effective. so we use that as a moshol to the effectiveness of tefilla and torah. and it gets the message across in a strong way. but we also know that we don't understand the exact mehalech Hashem uses and how this affects this and how that affects the other thing. be we are maamin be'emunah sheleima that this is how Hashem runs the world. when the kid takes it literally it's very cute;)

Yekutiel Weiss's avatar

So it really means that you can,'t control what happens in the world. Just a General prayer for help which may or may not occur.It's up to G-d if,how

,when, etc...So prayer is affective but may not help.

It is an important tool.The problem is a that there is no emphasis on the need for action,effort as much sspossible to accomplish your goals.Of course without prayer you may not succeed.But, אין סומכים עליך הנס.A false prophesy of imaginary dreams fired by an agenda that seeks to further praiseworthy goals.

A sad joke.אם כל הכבוד.

Shelly Halabe's avatar

If it's funny because it's cute that the kid is actually buying the story, the whole speech was pointless. It's either real as they claim or not real. And the rabbi laughing bends to the latter.

BANana's avatar

Read happy's old article "it's all Greek to me", or something like that. We speak different languages. "Every kapittel is like a bullet" is trying to bring out the point. The more Torah, tefillah, and zechusim there are, the stronger protection that Klal Yisroel has.

Natan Slifkin's avatar

So it's trying to bring out that claim by way of asserting gross exaggeration?

Yekutiel Weiss's avatar

It's called double think. You can pretend you believe and not exactly believe. It's useful as the party line.,especially for kids and those who don't know better.You yourself begin to sort of believe it. It helps not to face the reality.It helps one believe that he believes in it. The whole idea off insiders and outsiders is a ploy to. escape discussion and facing reality,that you need to work and that you should serve in the army etc..

test's avatar

Yet 'torah protects' is never explained as merely trying to 'bring out a point'. It's brought ad nauseum to provide a serious explanation as to why benei torah provide real protection (apparently not for beiter or kiryat seifer though, that require extra protection at times of high alert).

Hence the laughter.

Avi Rosenthal's avatar

That really worked in Europe 80 years ago, didn't it?

Daas Yochid's avatar

There was a blogger many years ago with a slifkin last name who made up the concept "machshava cholent" how all the different strands of machshava blend into one big mush in the average persons head. This feels similar.

Just Curious's avatar

Absent everything else wrong with this, the fact the R’ Feldman talks so blithely about Torah being a “bullet in an Arab’s head” (incidentally, not a “terrorist”, not a “Hamas fighter”, not even a “Palestinian”, but rather a generic Arab) and that these folks laugh like leitzim at the idea of a young student asking bloodthirstily “Can I choose which Arab to kill?” reflects a bloodlust and disregard for human life that is frankly horrifying.

We should be distressed by the fact that our soldiers are forced to kill in defense of our people and our land, not excited by it. And the notion that Torah itself (​דרכיה דרכי נעם וכל נתיבותיה שלום) would be valorized as a weapon for killing leaves me shaking my head.

Ari's avatar

By Arabs he meant terrorists. Try being dan likaf zchus. It works miracles.

Just Curious's avatar

1. He didn’t say “terrorists”.

2. He didn’t say the sweet little talmid specified “terrorists” in his bloodlust.

3. None of that matters in the slightest. As I made eminently clear in my comment, it’s the bloodlust that should horrify us: of R’ Feldman, of the talmid, and of all who would treat such a thing as a laughing matter.

Zundel Eysheshoker's avatar

What does the word 'meant' mean?

Avraham marcus's avatar

Ever read על נהרות בבל?

shimon.felix's avatar

Tle laughing about the tehillim killing a specific Arab is, as you indicate, quite telling. The Haredi world spends vast amounts of time, energy, and money glorifying what they do and denigrating what everyone else in the world does. I assume they do this because, if one stops to think about it, they do so very little, and everyone else does so much, most of which - modern medicine, the entire economic system, communications, transportation, government, architecture, everything , really - the Haredi community is happy to make use of without contributing anything, so they denigrate it all so as to not see admit how parasitic their day to day lives are. So, the whole "learning is fighting" thing is really a kind of joke - these shgotzim are fighting and dying, we, as with most everything else, don't bother to get involved, and, as justification, we'll pretend that we are "really" doing the job of fighting the war. Not so deep down inside, close to the surface, in fact, they know it's just baloney, part of their self justifying superstructure, so when someone seems to take it seriously, literally, they, quite appropriately, laugh.

Ari's avatar

Yes felix...you got it. The one who really helps is you.

The amount of time you spend glued to your TV does much more than praying and learning. If only you could watch several channels at once. Then moshiach would have come already.

Tim's avatar

If you don't believe in Tefillah just say so.. Your cheap jokes and mockery of a fundamental to Jewish faith show your true self.

Stop pretending you're observant and religious, you are a textbook atheist.

Just be honest with yourself and admit it publicly - you'll feel much better once you're out the closet.

Tim's avatar

No sorry lol!

Will repost on main

Yosef Hirsh's avatar

According to Slifkin the only Tefilah and Tehilim that works are the ones that have not been said for the IDF.

Otherwise Tefilah and Tehilim don't work because they are a " rational form of self reflection".

Nothing to see here folks...move along.

Charles Joseph's avatar

The Rabbi here seems to believe in nothing at all other than what he doesn't believe in?

Ruth's avatar

Does it scale? If I read ק"כ, is it like a small bullet, but if I read קי"ט, am I dropping MOABs?

Sholom Rafailov's avatar

It was funny bc it doesnt really mean that a tehillim equals a bullet. But that with each good deed done for the sake of the soldiers, the soldiers have more merit to win the war.

Tim's avatar

If you don't believe in Tefillah just say so.. Your cheap jokes and mockery of a fundamental to Jewish faith show your true self.

Stop pretending you're observant and religious, you are a textbook atheist.

Just be honest with yourself and admit it publicly - you'll feel much better once you're out the closet.

Nachum's avatar

You know, I was waiting for the train just now and a young woman got off the elevator to the platform. She clearly has some sort of severe spinal deformity or something similar, and could only walk, haltingly, with the aid of a wheeled walker frame.

She was in uniform.

Not apparently religious, either.

I have no doubt she could have gotten an instant exemption from all service, and no one would have held it against her at all.

And she's hardly the only one. The IDF has entire units of soldiers with disabilities, severe autism, even Down's Syndrome.

And then I thought of Schreiber's line- which anyone who's been paying attention at all the last month already knew was completely untrue- that absent a draft, only "perhaps a few crazy mizrochniks [sic*]" would serve. (This is of course projection, as the main body of refusees would be *his* people.) How ugly.

*Mizrachi ceased to exist in 1956, but that's typical of these types.

משכיל בינה's avatar

"And she's hardly the only one. The IDF has entire units of soldiers with disabilities, severe autism, even Down's Syndrome."

Maybe the IDF should focus on actually winning a war for the first time in 50 years, and less on weird stuff like this.

Mark's avatar

Maybe if you were a little more in touch with the history of the last 50 years, you would know that every one of those wars ended when the international community forced Israel to stop fighting because too many Arab human shields were dying, not because Israel had any lack of success in military terms.

משכיל בינה's avatar

You don't get to say 'we would have won if only X factor had been different'. The reality in the world we actually live in that the IDF lost all these wars. The logical response to the exact same dynamic playing out over an over again is to develop a new military strategy that is less reliant on aerial bombardment. This is how the early Zionists responded to failure. But ever since Begin came to power, Zionism has become about uncritical reverence for the incompetent state institutions combined with moaning about how the world isn't fair. The first step to solving your problem is admitting you have one.

Mark's avatar

Sounds like you didn't actually read my comment. Not only were you unfamiliar with the degree to which Israeli actions are constrained by international politics, but you didn't seem to understand it even after I explained it explicitly. Instead you made a novice level suggestion ("develop a new military strategy that is less reliant on aerial bombardment") which wouldn't help with the international politics and might actually make them worse, and spun a psychological fairy tale around it.

Ari's avatar

Maskil Bina. You are downright insane. Worse than slifkin. Stop attacking Israel for fighting against terrorists. Seriously.

משכיל בינה's avatar

Honestly, nationalism is just not good for people's cognitive functioning. Even basic reading comprehension goes to pot. Where did I 'attack Israel for fighting terrorists'?

Ari's avatar

You attacked them for losing wars, whatever that means....they actually won wars...but even if they lost ...that would be disgusting to attack poland for getting bombed by nazis....you attack them for bombing gaza and only getting limited hostages..as if it's up to them exactly how many hostages are freed by the terrorists...

They should just demand it, right? You don't like them endlessly showing off their down syndrome units? What the hell does that mean?

Yes, you are bat $%^& crazy.

Ofcourse if you were rhe Prime Minister, no wars would happen...if captives were taken, you would get them out immediately...thats the problem these days. 1) Jews pray and learn Torah too much and 2) you are not the Prime Minister.

Indeed the world has gone to pot.

Nachum's avatar

All of those people actually contribute in real, and often unique, ways. Maybe you should get a little השכלה and בינה before mouthing off about things you are ignorant of. That, or change your handle.

משכיל בינה's avatar

They contribute to what exactly? The IDF screwing up and allowing savages to rampage around the country killing people at will for an entire day like an African failed state? Losing 8 successive wars? Spending 49 days bombing the **** out of Gaza to get 1/5 of the hostages? Is it just a coincidence that armies with successful militaries don't endlessly show off about their empowered female soldiers and Downs Syndrome units? I happen to know a bit the family of a soldier who died on Shemini Atzeret. He would be a alive today had he been wearing body armour, but his unit was sent out without any because the IDF is chaotic and dysfunctional.

One of the frequent critiques orthodox Jews used to make about Zionism is that it was a plot to make us like the nations, but, honestly, at this point, that would be an improvement.

Avraham marcus's avatar

What are you doing for israel then? Fressing cholent?

Ari's avatar

Yikes. Maskil Bina...I can't handle slifkins attacks but you are also suffering from a disease. The army is fighting very hard and you are harassing them for their 49 days of bombing and past wars. Sorry but you are crazy. You need help.

Chaim Perlin's avatar

I agree. The vast majority of people serve out of a sense of idealism and responsibility to the nation. Kol hakavod to them.

Shim's avatar

First you attack for not davening...now for davening? If its not hatred that is driving this relentless rant then what is (Serious question)

Ari's avatar

Its pure love for am yisrael thar drives slifkin to the edges of hights of sanity.

Moshe M's avatar

I get the feeling that the reason why it's funny to them is because clearly unlike a bullet they all know you cannot choose which Arab to kill. To them, tehilim are more like indiscriminate machine gun fire or carpet bombs that just kill Arabs period. To them all Arabs in gaza are equaly guilty so the concept of picking specific Arabs is funny.

Richie's avatar

The reason they were laughing is because they realised how stupid what he said was.

And Rabbi Aharon Feldman laughed because he too realised how stupid what he said was.

Clearly, he is well out of his depths. And that is the best Rabbi that Agudah can put forward as their spokesman.

I learnt the hard way during Covid that these Rabbis are far less impressive than we are led to believe. And that is me being nice about them. My true impressions, from my own personal conversations with some Chareidi Gedolim, are best kept to myself.

Ari's avatar

Best kept to yourself? So telling. Richie, if you would spend more time watching TV there would be less problems. Every hour of TV kills one terrorist.

Shim's avatar

This maturity really adds weight to your opinion

Commentator 10952's avatar

Perhaps you don't know rabbi Feldman. He would NEVER EVER think that ANYTHING he's said is stupid. He laughed because he's so immensely proud of how clever he is, so much smarter than everyone else. And laughter is contagious, especially within an audience that identifies with the one who is laughing.

He loves proving things with stories.

For another example of him saying something incredibly ignorant yet crowing with pride over how more clever he is than everyone else :

https://youtu.be/0-ls1NWqm6A?si=2QevMzOcYz78pEx0

Leiby Wasser's avatar

You seem to be mocking the concept of Tefillah, or of reciting Tehillim. Perhaps you could write a clarification?

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Nov 26, 2023
Comment deleted
Shim's avatar

Thats not actually their claim

Henry Rosenberg's avatar

Sadly, the idea of tehilim being a bullet is misguided. Physical facts are ignored at one’s peril. Enven the author of Tehilim, דוד המלך would consider such a statement ludicrous, as he states in 18 מְלַמֵּ֣ד יָ֭דַי לַמִּלְחָמָ֑ה וְֽנִחֲתָ֥ה קֶֽשֶׁת־נְ֝חוּשָׁ֗ה זְרוֹעֹתָֽי׃

Shim's avatar

You are not going to catch these 2 rabbanim out on something like that I'm sorry you can't really believe they are that superficial

BANana's avatar

They were laughing at secularists like you. You don't understand how tefillah works, hence yours and that student's confusion.

Natan Slifkin's avatar

So the student was a secularist?

Pray explain the student's funny misunderstanding.

Chaim Perlin's avatar

I don't condone Banana's rudeness. But I believe his point is that both the student and you don't understand what the chareidi phrase "every Tehillim is a bullet means", for different reasons. The student because of his immaturity, and you because of your apparent unfamiliarity with chareidi ideology. For example, a child might hear the phrase Iron Dome and being unfamiliar with it, he might wonder where the metallic dome above his head is. But in both cases, it is figurative language being used. Does that help explain it? I admit it is a bit confusing, but hopefully the commenters here cleared it up, even if they are not as nice as I would hope.

Natan Slifkin's avatar

Great. Please explain what tje Rabbonim were figuratively saying.

Chaim Perlin's avatar

They were saying that tefilah is tremendously effective, a belief you must certainly share.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Nov 26, 2023
Comment removed
shulman's avatar

i thought natan was being pretty nice in this article. he asked what i believe to be an honest question. i'd suggest responding in kind if nothing because it's more effective...

Zundel Eysheshoker's avatar

You seem to confuse form and substance.

The rule of thumb is, "it's not how you say it, but what you say." When a person writes a polite article that proves that someone else is 'an offense to the olfactory senses', he has not said anything nicer than the person who writes 'this guy stinks'.

The nimshal should be self-understood.

Chaim Perlin's avatar

I agree that Rabbi Slifkin was asking an honest question. I don't think he understands the chareidi world very well, and thinks that "every Tehillim is a bullet" is literal, rather than expressing the tremendous power of Tefillah. Hence his abject perplexity of Rabbi Feldman's amusement. However, I have no doubt that once Rabbi Slifkin sees the comments here explaining it, he will change his opinion. I don't see the place for rudeness here when dealing with a sincere question from a sincere questioner.

Charles Joseph's avatar

It doesn't matter one way or another. Nothing penetrates this rabbi's skull.

BANana's avatar

Chaim, read this article and let me know what you think:

https://irrationalistmodoxism.substack.com/p/its-all-greek-to-me

I think the author very astutely explains what we're seeing here. Do you agree?

Chaim Perlin's avatar

That is a very interesting blog, is it new? I don't agree with the author's rude and mocking tone, especially when dealing with a sincere scholar of Judaism like Rabbi Slifkin, and it probably falls into the category of bizayon talmid chacham, but I agree with the overall message of that post. He is right on target there.

BANana's avatar

I didn't think he was being nice at all. Maybe if I came across this post as a one-off I would think so, but it's part of a series of filthy, bigoted posts.

shulman's avatar

i agree he's bigoted but i thought this post was more genuine. i can't blame you at all if you disagree

Chaim Perlin's avatar

Agreed, the Rabbi seems to be questioning sincerely and deserves a proper answer, which I see commenters endeavoring to provide.

test's avatar

Is it right for a godol to laugh at a talmid?

Avi Rosenthal's avatar

Like they worked 80 years ago in Europe?

shulman's avatar

to paraphrase a friend:

so to be clear - you don't believe tefila works, like at all, correct?

Avi Rosenthal's avatar

Rashi on this week's parasha: הִתְקִין עַצְמוֹ לִשְׁלוֹשָׁה דְבָרִים: לְדוֹרוֹן, לִתְפִלָּה, וּלְמִלְחָמָה. Not just לתפילה.

Avi Rosenthal's avatar

Not unless accompanied by practical action. Like why should God accept prayers for the recovery of a cancer sufferer unless the prayer is accompanied by something like a donation to the Cancer society? If I were God I would expect the petitioner to put (at least) his money where his mouth is.

BANana's avatar

R' Avigdor Miller addresses that at length. Which is exactly my point. Also, according to R' Dovid Soloveitchik who was a first-hand eyewitness, at least where he was, there wasn't all that much tefillah going on there at all.

Arturo Macias's avatar

What about Poland? There Jews were very observant, weren’t they? Far more than in 1967 Israel for sure...

Eli's avatar

What about the destruction of the Temple? That had their own army but were defeated! Clearly armies are useless by your logic.

BANana's avatar

It happens to be that R' Dovid Soloveitchik was in Poland at the time of the war. He said that there was very little tefillah there as the war started and the Nazis invaded. Contrast that to EY where they fasted and prayed and were miraculously saved from Rommel. Also, Chazal are clear that if Klal Yisroel goofs and invokes Heavenly wrath, everyone is in danger, even the yereim.