As discussed in a previous post, Who Is An Israeli?, the parties that ran in the Israeli elections for change were usually objecting to one or more (and generally all) of the following three aspects of the previous government:
(A) The wholesale exemption from the charedi community from army service and any civic duties, while giving them tens of billions to perpetuate a lifestyle of freeloading, which severely weakens and will eventually collapse the state;
(B) Creating a coalition with Ben-Gvir and others like him, a man convicted multiple times of terror-related offenses and who was formerly considered beyond the pale (even by Bibi!), and who has dramatically weakened Israel’s international standing (and brought out the Arab vote!).
(C) The general attempt to harm the liberal democratic nature/ rule of law of the country, in particular the attempt to prevent the government from having any checks on its power. (Most people support some degree of judicial reform, but nowhere near to the extremes that the past government tried to create.)
Now, before the elections, the three largest change parties (Eisenkot’s Yashar, Bennet’s B’Yachad, and Lieberman’s Yisrael Beitenu) did not differentiate between the order of priorities in the above. In fairness, it could be argued that they did not need to, since the indications were that they would be able to form a coalition without needing either Bibi, charedim, or Arabs. But when the election results came out, it turned out that this was far from the case.
And so everyone is stuck. Nobody at all in the Knesset has enough support to form the kind of coalition that they had wanted and promised.
So what happens? Repeat elections will either repeat the same stalemate or enable Bibi to increase his numbers. Accordingly, the only thing that makes sense is for Eisenkot, Bennett and Lieberman to sacrifice one or more of their goals. (Some people are yelling that they are hypocrites and frauds, but this is not the case; half a loaf is better than none.) But which goals should be sacrificed?
Powerful arguments can be made in every direction. Yet in terms of what’s actually happening, it seems that Lieberman is willing to compromise on enlisting charedim, while Eisenkot is willing to compromise on forming a government without any Arab support. Bennett has kept quiet, and nobody seems to know his order of priorities. Meanwhile, the order of priorities may itself have shifted since the elections, with Bibi being investigated by the police on suspicion of fabricating a story that the election was “stolen,” which if true would make it even more important to remove him from power.
Given that Leiberman and Eisenkot are only willing to make opposing compromises, it still seems that they will not be able to form a coalition, and we’ll be heading for another round of elections. But even if that happens, there are two silver linings here.
First is at least voters will have more clarity regarding how Leiberman and Eisenkot prioritize their goals. There is also now increased clarity that the Ashkenazi charedim, who are explicitly ready to go with whoever promises them endless army exemptions along with vast school funding that does not require any general studies, are not neccessarily part of the Right.
Second is that even without a government, the fact of there now being a majority who are opposed to the previous government means that important changes can be made. Key positions, such as Knesset Speaker and various committee roles, can be transferred to vastly superior Change MKs.
Thus, for example, the new Finance Committee chair is Liran Ben-Horin of B'Yachad. She replaces Hanoch Dov Milwidsky of the Likud. Milwidsky, who aside from calling on people to avoid the court system and being accused by two women of sexual assault, also tried to cover up and excuse the Likud-charedi billion shekel theft.
Ben-Horin has pledged to examine government spending closely, to find out where the money is going, and wants to on increasing participation in education, military service and employment, and prioritizing such people for spending. The goal, she says, is to return taxpayers’ money to those who serve in the IDF and work and to “stop funding that incentivizes [charedi] draft evasion and poverty traps.” Note that in the long run, this benefits charedim more than anyone, saving them from their own leadership.
Meanwhile, on a personal level, I got involved in my own dispute with someone from a different community, which ended up being happily resolved.
As an Englishman married to an American for nearly 26 years, I thought I knew all the differences between our two varieties of the English language. I know that when my wife asks to pass the chips, she really means crisps. I understand that when she tells me that I have a stain on my pants, she is referring to my trousers. I realized that if I talk about using a torch, she will think that I mean a flaming stick rather than a flashlight. I learned that if I talk about the rubbers I collected as a child, I should use the American word “erasers.”
But the other day, after 25 years of marriage, I learned a new one!
We were talking about flying somewhere for our anniversary, and we came up with the idea of a certain country. I looked up the prices for airfare, and told my wife how much it costs for a return ticket. She asked, “But what about the flight there?”
Eventually, we realized that what British people call a return ticket, Americans call a roundtrip. But until we got to that realization, I was utterly bewildered, and she was bewildered by my bewilderment, and we were both getting increasingly confused and frustrated.
“But how much does it cost to get THERE?!”
“It’s a RETURN TICKET!”
“Yes, exactly, so how much does it cost to GET THERE??!”
“IT’S A RETURN TICKET!!!”
May we all merit to understand why those we disagree with have the views that they do!




Canada and the UK have at times had minority governments in their parliamentary systems. That isn't possible in Israel?