There’s a fascinating similarity between what ultra-Orthodoxy has been doing in the last few decades, and what supporters of the previous Israeli government have been doing in the last few months and especially the last 24 hours.
It’s well-known that ultra-Orthodoxy has been steadily sliding to the right. But it’s especially striking when this takes place to the extent that the original normative tradition becomes so forgotten (or censored) that people can’t even imagine that it ever existed, and it seems shocking and utterly unacceptable.
One example close to my heart is that regarding Talmudic statements about the natural world. It used to be well accepted that significant Rishonim were of the view that the Sages sometimes discussed astronomy (in fact it’s all of the Rishonim), and that some of their statements about astronomy turned out to be errant (which was the view of most Rishonim). Nowadays, however, it’s widely considered an unequivocal fact that the Sages were always referring instead to “deeper” matters, and it’s inconceivable that they were mistaken. Thus, when I published a book claiming that it is acceptable to say that their statements were errant, this was banned as heresy, in some cases by rabbis who couldn’t even imagine that such a view ever existed at all, let alone that it was normative!
Another example is swordfish. There is absolutely no doubt that Jewish communities happily ate swordfish for thousands of years, and the halachic basis for doing so was very clearly discussed by the Acharonim. This continued into the early twentieth century, and was so accepted that swordfish was listed as a kosher fish by the Agudas HaRabbanim of America. Yet nowadays, not only will virtually no kashrut organization certify swordfish, most people do not believe that it was ever eaten!
Another example that someone pointed out to me recently is mixed seating at weddings and other events. Nowadays this would be inconceivable in yeshivish circles. Yet in the early twentieth century, you’d find mixed seating not only at weddings in the yeshivish community, but even at dinners held by Agudas Yisrael!
No doubt there is a long list of similar examples, and I’d love to hear more. But meanwhile, the same phenomenon has strikingly occurred in Israeli politics in the last 24 hours, in two ways.
First is the professed horror that Yashar MK Matan Kahana was elected to the position of Speaker of the Knesset with the support of Arab votes. MK Tvika Mor even tore kriyah at the Knesset podium! But aside from the fact that Kahana is a terrific person and mensch and religious Zionist and received the majority of Zionist votes, it’s hardly some unthinkable thing to benefit from Arab votes - Bibi’s coalition was happy to do it in 2023 in order to bring down the Lapid-Bennett government!
Then there are breathless announcements about the shocking fact that the Change coalition has enabled Ahmad Tibi to become Deputy Speaker of the Knesset! Tibi, an Arab! And moreover from the Joint List! And moreover a person who has glorified Shaheeds! Even people who were not fans of the previous government are shocked upon learning this.
But there’s a lot of information that is being omitted by those screaming about how unnacceptable and shocking and dangerous this is. In some cases it’s because they don’t know the information, and in some cases they are deliberately withholding it in order to manipulate people.
First is that there are nine Deputy Speakers. They are selected from across both coalition and opposition factions to ensure proportional party representation. This is how it’s always been.
Second is that for sixteen of the last twenty years, there has been an Arab Deputy Speaker of the Knesset.
And it’s not only Mansour Abbas from Raam who has held this position, but also someone from the Joint List, who held this position for sixteen of the last twenty years. His name is Ahmad Tibi.
So, this “shocking and dangerous new development” is actually something that has already existed for many years, with Likud’s approval!
When you try pointing this out to anti-Change agitators, they counter with two arguments. One is that it’s only now that we realize that Tibi is such a dangerous person. But we’ve always known that Tibi is an anti-Zionist; he used to work for Arafat! And what they don’t tell you is that Tibi’s statements about Shaheeds were made back in 2012 (when his intent was debated in the Knesset, and he was censured), and he was still re-endorsed afterwards by Likud as deputy speaker!
The other argument proffered is that “things are different after October 7th.” To be sure, lots of things are different after October 7th. For example, we now know that the idea of having a small army is no longer tenable. But why would things be different regarding having Tibi as one of the deputy speakers? If anything, in light of the accelerating international sanctions against Israel and the harm they will cause, it is beneficial to show that such a person can be deputy speaker of the Knesset.
Tibi’s role as one of the deputy speakers has never had any significant practical harmful effects. It didn’t have anything to do with the worst civilian disaster in Israel’s history (Meron), the worst security disaster in Israel’s history (Oct 7), the near-miss of the second worst security disaster in Israel’s history (terrorist airline pilots not being screened), the increasing international isolation of Israel, the efforts to strengthen charedi patterns of army avoidance and freeloading off the economy, the enormous level of political corruption in Israel and its results. All those problems, and the ongoing dangers they represent, are the responsibility of the same people shrieking that appointing Tibi as one of the deputy speakers is the danger.
Is it not obvious that all this is about their manipulative efforts to distract from those problems?




