152 Comments
User's avatar
shulman's avatar

it's not an anti slifkin blog. its an honest chareidi viewpoint

Eli B's avatar

I'm no גדול הדור or נביא but it seems uncanny that a disaster that will inevitably unite the country, occurs after the most divisive period in the country in recent times

Notleast the disgraceful scenes בשעת נעילה

(קשה עלי פרידתכם, said by Hashem on שמיני עצרת, is explained by some to refer to פירוד between segments of Jewry)

May ה' send us ישועות ונחמות בקרוב

Charles's avatar

Are you victim blaming or did I miss something here?

Eli B's avatar

Not victim blaming at all. Searching for meaning and hope in a seemingly hopeless situation.

Anyway, ever heard of יפשפש במעשיו

Eli B's avatar

See here:

https://archive.ph/4VwiB

"The strike was intended to hit Israel while it appeared distracted by internal political divisions over Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government."

And here:

https://www.timesofisrael.com/gantz-liberman-open-to-emergency-unity-government-but-demand-say-in-waging-war/

"Some observers have pointed to unprecedented societal divisions wrought by the government’s plans to overhaul the judiciary and attendant protests as having given Hamas the impression that Israel was weakened and ripe for attack."

Garvin's avatar

Armchair nonsense. There's never a time when Israel isn't dealing with internal division, and never a time when its enemies aren't plotting to attack it. The fighting over judicial reform didn't prompt the attack, but it makes all the Hillel Halkins of the world, who forgot who our REAL enemies are, look like fools. [Edit - and I see now intelligence already shows this attack was planned more than a year ago, long before the protests.]

The only question right now is how massive the response. Most seem to feel it has to be overwhelming, nothing less than 50,000 dead. No sophisticates, no overthinking it, none of this brainiac "Oh, we can't do that" stupidity. Do it, and deal with condemnations later. When we take our own counsel, like bombing the reactor and the preemptive strike of '67, it works out. When we listen to others, like Oslo and the Gaza expulsion, this is what we get back. For God's sake, how long will Israel fail to learn from history. Turn Gaza into a parking lot, and do it now.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Oct 9, 2023
Comment removed
Ephraim's avatar

You mistranslated יפשפש במעשיו

shulman's avatar

Hope your virus goes away...

mb's avatar

In terms of percentage of populations, this is by far the worst terrorist attack in history. In terms of sheer numbers, it's probably 2nd to 9/11.

Mikhail Olivson's avatar

By now, far worse than 9/11.

mb's avatar

Are you sure? More than 3,000?

Mikhail Olivson's avatar

Quick math. US population in 2001 was 285 million. Israel is currently just under 10.

Multiply 700 by 28.5, you get 19,950. So essentially, more than 6 times 9/11. Plus hostages.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Oct 9, 2023
Comment deleted
mb's avatar

Huh? read my initial comment.

Michael Sedley's avatar

May the A-lmighty protect your daughter together with all other soldiers in Israel.

May the IDF, with the help of G-d, quickly free the people of Gaza from the Hamas regime, bring the captives home safely, provide comfort to the hundreds of bereaved families, send a quick and full recovery to the thousands of injured, and bring a long lasting peace to the residents of the South so never again will the need to run to bomb shelters in the night, and bring peace to all of עם ישרשאל.

Just Curious's avatar

R’ Slifkin, davening for the safety of your family along with acheinu kol beit yisrael.

Please keep us updated.

Moshe's avatar

Rabbi, regarding you suggestion for mental health services I am in touch with the head of a large Jewish mental health org in the US who would like to offer services. please message me misaacson [at] gmail

Don Coyote's avatar

My preliminary thoughts, FWIW:

1. Being Nosei B'ol, Gevald...! Davening! Being Marbeh Zechuyos!

2. Getting off the computer asap and doing that.

3. A great Israeli Rosh Yeshiva said about how the YK war came about, that it's explicit in Avos that among other things, Ivus Hadin causes war, and not long before the YK war a terrible Ivus Hadin had occurred with the implicit(?) support of the Israeli gov't . (IOW, he looked outwards. Did he also look inwards? I'm sure.)

4. Why are people busy with their SINGLE causer? What about zeh v'zeh garmu? What about Lo Nechtam G'zar Dinam Ela Al Hagezel by the Mabul, that there were multiple factors

5. Looking outward while looking inward is fine, and when done very properly, important.

https://www.sefaria.org/Rambam_on_Pirkei_Avot.1.17.9?lang=bi&with=all&lang2=en

"And the fourth division [of speech] is the beloved, and that is speech in praise of intellectual virtues or dispositional virtues and in disgrace of both types of vice - to awaken the soul to the virtues with stories and songs, and to prevent the vices in these same ways. ... to disgrace the bad about their vices, so that their action and their memory be disgraced in the eyes of people and that they distance themselves from them and not act according to their practices."

6. An element in Bibi's Uman speech, and other of his public statements, (such as when French Jewry experienced terrorism and he invited them to Israel), is that thanks to the state, Israel is the safest place. With this, according to my conjecture, he opened the door for the Midas Hadin to settle accounts with us for our sins, and he be chastised.

7. Back to #1 & #2.

Rafael's avatar

I do not want to cause unrelated debates, but what do you as a rationalist think your davening will achieve for the safety or success of israeli soldiers?

Mikhail Olivson's avatar

Rationalism still has God as part of the equation. That's a strange question

shulman's avatar

btw, can you share your thoughts on this situation going on? i'd love to hear your perspective. if you want you can email me at davidschulmannn@gmail.com

Rafael's avatar

Sure.

In the last days I have been watching constantly al-jazeera arabic and israeli media.

In the last years, more and more arab countries have normalized their relationship with israel, fearing the shia iranian terrorism and threat. If you want more context on that, here: https://open.substack.com/pub/irrationalistmodoxism/p/do-we-misrepresent-our-opponents?r=2rw0fd&utm_campaign=comment-list-share-cta&utm_medium=web&comments=true&commentId=39871087

Hamas sees itself abandoned, so they started this surprise attack, utilizing the internal israeli divisions.

Hamas promised not to harm civilians (which for them includes only old people and children). All other israelis, since they are serving in the army, are military combatants and in hamas' view necessary targets, hence they shot these people on the rave party.

(There have been rumours on twitter about israeli women raped, but I haven't see any evidence. The story of 40 beheaded babies seems to be false, too and a picture of caged israeli children turned out to be an old picture of palestinian children).

Cuz Hamas goal with all these hostages is to get as many palestinians as possible out of prison. Last time israel released a 1000 palestinians for one captured soldier, imagine then now.

I think Hamas' strategy is wrong.

In Islamic Law, there is nothing legally wrong in killing any armed zionist in a state of war (whether woman or man, whether rabbi or layman and it doesn't have to be a soldier of the regular army tzahal, but even e.g. an armed settler like those in the west bank).

However, this indiscriminate killing and bombing is a war-crime, considering that many of the 1000 killed israelis are Arab Muslims (mostly the bedouins who live there in the south of israel) and who do not serve the army, rendering hamas' justification futile.

Non-Muslims are, in Islamic Law, in one of 4 possible categories. In three of these (dhimmi, mu'ahad, mustaman) it is prohibited to kill them, in one (harbi) only armed combatants can be killed (which could include women, old people and monks, with the condition that they are themselves armed and trying to kill you, but it is usually prohibited to kill them https://sunnah.com/muslim:1744b).

For references from classical Islamic jurists on war, see the book al-Badaai as-Sania from the jurist al-Kasani (12th century) https://shamela.ws/index.php/book/8183/1832 and the book al-Mughni from Ibn Qudama al-Maqdisi (13th century) https://shamela.ws/book/8463/4225 and the book Ahkam ahli dhimma by Ibn al-Qayyim (14th century).

Except violating Islamic Law, I see a second problem with hamas' attack. The zionist retaliation will be much more brutal. Hamas violated this instruction by the Prophet saws: https://www.abuaminaelias.com/dailyhadithonline/2019/02/05/believers-not-seek-hardship/

Moving away from the strategy, the logic behind the attack itself is this: israel is built on zionism, the idea that jews must get an independent jewish state in zion i.e. palestine. But for such a state, one inevitably needs a majority jewish population which requires the ethnic cleansing or even genocide of the current majority population i.e. Arab muslims and Arab xtians. Some of them can stay (so called arab israelis) but most of them must go away.

Hence, for hamas, zionism is an irredemable ideology and its construct israel must be destroyed.

Emotionally I understand and even support this view. I have nothing against a jewish state in palestine per se, if there had been a realistic solution made by both sides without ethnic cleasing and personally I would even be ready to grant jews a specific place on the Temple mountain for davening.

But purely logically and legally speaking, I think that Hamas' attack was wrong.

Muslims know this too. Years ago, even before the saudi normalization with israel, the Saudi Grand Mufti Abdulaziz Aal Shaykh condemend Hamas: https://www.aljazeera.net/news/2017/11/15/%D9%81%D8%AA%D9%88%D9%89-%D8%B9%D8%A8%D8%AF-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B9%D8%B2%D9%8A%D8%B2-%D8%A2%D9%84-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B4%D9%8A%D8%AE-%D8%AA%D8%AB%D9%8A%D8%B1-%D8%B1%D9%81%D8%B6

But the argument is always, that Palestinians have no other choice but to fight. I disagree with that assumption.

If you want to know what palestinians in my view should do instead, see: https://open.substack.com/pub/irrationalistmodoxism/p/do-we-misrepresent-our-opponents?r=2rw0fd&utm_campaign=comment-list-share-cta&utm_medium=web&comments=true&commentId=39986986

shulman's avatar

at least some the rapings have been confirmed by videos which i won't go into detail here, but just one example of many, one video was shown on cnn, and they spoke with the mother of the girl in the video, shani louk, and got permission to air it to show the atrocities - which makes it sound pretty real... we are always cautious when watching these kinds of things that perhaps its not a valid source, but there were definitely some confirmed.

the beheading is hearsay right now and we may never know if true, but there were definitely atrocities that were confirmed very clearly (as things go, meaning through solid journalism).

many israeli's btw don't support this whole occupation thing as a principle because of the conflicts it's causing. many prominent rabbis were against the establishment of a state because it isn't necessarily the appropriate hishtadlus (human efforts) to be the safe haven the Zionists claimed it would be. but we have no problem living there and even appreciate having what we believe to be our homeland back after all this time.

for the most part things have become so radicalized that at this point a two state solution is simply impossible, which is what happens when we stop being able to trust each other to make a treaty, and this goes both ways of course. but at this point with Hamas and Hezbollah and others, with Iran backing them, it really is an them or them situation and no one knows how to get out of this mess:(

as in all politics, we never really know who to trust and we all have our biases, and i hope this can be resolved without more pain

i also understand that many Palestinians do not back Hamas and we have nothing against them (you)

as a side, it seems unfair to say that any random citizen of israel shoudld b fair game as long as they are armed, because they are only armed for protection. because they live close that is a crime?

and the next q is, what is israel's response supposed to be now, but to fight back?

Rafael's avatar

If the crimes are true I condemn them. You will notice that Muslims do not have a problem with condemning crimes. Most of the time we are just calling out fake news, exaggerated or decontextualized reports and especially double standards. In other words, just as we are condemning crimes, it would be nice if e.g. the chief rabbinate were to condemn the thousands of murdered palestinian women and children over the years.

Instead I saw orthodox rabbis making analogies to amalek (and you know better than me the halakha regarding their fate). Palestinians themsleves do not want a genocide, neither the xtian nor the Muslim ones.

You can imagine that most if not all of these Hamas fighters have dead relatives murdered by zionists and that this fueled their hatred.

P. S. Read my statement again. I said "in a state of war", I am not saying jews in israel can't own weapon against crime.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Oct 12, 2023
Comment removed
Rafael's avatar

"My personal, practical understanding is that Islamic scholarly theory plays little or no role in the Hamas guidebook." I agree with you rabbi goldberg.

If you mean by "different approaches" a possible islamic legal argument for a recognition of israel, I think that palazzi is wrong for defending the current zionist entity.

As I said in other comments, in essence, we have nothing against a jewish state per se, provided that both sides agreed on realistic functioning states without ethnic cleansing.

God does affirm in the Qur'an that He gave the holy Land to the israelites. However, He also constantly points out that jews should convert to Islam and accept Muhammad saws as Gods Final Messenger,. Thats an important point that palazzi leaves out. Comparing israel to what the israelites got is a false equivalence, too.

Ismail al-Faruqi was a palestinian politologist. He used to be an arab nationalist and supremacist. However, he renounced that and made Islam his sole political, legal and ideological view. Besides the inevitable zionist ethnic cleansing and the theological differences between Islam and judaism, Faruqi identified a third problem with israel that palazzi did not consider. The zionist project and entity called israel is not religious anyway (a zionist who even disbelieves in the Torah cares even less about the Qur'an as a reason for the establishment of Israel). Its a secularist, nationalist (and at that time socialist) state, that Muslims could never accept.

Faruqi asked for the renouncing of arab nationalism, secularism and remnants of colonial law in these contemporary postcolonial artificial arab states that we have today (I think he would agree on the establishment of a unified Caliphate).

In the same token, he argued that israel must become a rabbinical medinat halakha and get rid of the socialist, secularist and democratic zionist baggage. In such a case, an Islamic state and a jewish state could continuously live in peace together in a confederation (whoch would mean a state similar to the shengen accord we have in europe). Such a jewish state, where jews follow jewish law, Muslims Sharia, xtians whatever they want, that would be acceptable. Cuz historically, thats how Caliphates worked: Muslims have their law, jews their and the only thing was that jews had to pay the jizya tax, which did not apply in times where the Caliphate could not military protect the jewish population. this was especially the case at border regions. If the siraelis set up their own army and protection, one might drop the jizya too.

I think this plan would be reasonable taking the current situation into account (at least from my Muslims and your jewish perpsective, a secularist israeli or secularist atheist arab,might be siffering a heart attack reading this)

But as long as the whole "oNly dEmocRacy iN tHe miDdle EasT" propaganda trope continues, israel is considered a foreign, colonialist and implanted element

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Oct 12, 2023
Comment deleted
Rafael's avatar

I do not know whether the average Gazan civilian thinks the same. I haven't seen any representative surveys on that. I do not know what the average israeli thinks, either. But certainly, the Hamas and Israeli political leadership do treat this as a 2 way struggle for survival. For netanyahu, this disgrace is also a struggle for his political survival.

Ephraim's avatar

Let's ask the greatest rationalist, shall we?

He answers:

אבל אם לא יזעקו ולא יריעו אלא יאמרו דבר זה ממנהג העולם אירע לנו וצרה זו נקרה נקרית. הרי זו דרך אכזריות וגורמת להם להדבק במעשיהם הרעים. ותוסיף הצרה צרות אחרות.

Yekutiel Weiss's avatar

No one said that our religious and moral actions are not part of the equation.Noone excluded prayer and Tshuva from the equation. At the same time natural events and consequences are also part of the equation.Human actions and effort are crucial but not enough to overcome Jewish religious failures. We pray for G-d's chesed and His Rachmanut.

Garvin's avatar

Note that well: the person is called an אכזר, a "cruel" person, not a רשע or a שוטה. I heard the reason in the name of R. Ruderman: bc such a person is insensible and unfeeling, and this is where the roots of cruelty lie. An inability to empathize or feel the suffering of others.

Yekutiel Weiss's avatar

Slifkins rationalism, as he explains it, does not exclude prayer or other Torah concepts. He is a faithful Torah believing Jew.His position rejects mysticism as a regular answer to religious questions and understanding of important religious events. Of course payer is basic to our faith and in no way does his rationalism reject it.You are confusing his rationalism that rejects religion and spiritual actions.

Howard Schranz's avatar

Rafael, praying is just something to say that will offend almost no1. At a time like this, we can still use meaningless (to us) phrases. Stalin opened all the shuttered churches during ww2.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Oct 10, 2023
Comment removed
Rafael's avatar

Sure, read my reply to david shulman

dov's avatar

Wow didn't know it "was probably the largest number of Jews murdered in a single day since the Holocaust". Is that total Jews or just civilians?

User's avatar
Comment removed
Oct 10, 2023
Comment removed
shulman's avatar

i'm actually on your side of the slifkin debate, but is this the place to yell at him, when you're literally screaming about setting aside our differences? that line he wrote bothered me too but right now Hamas is our enemy, not slifkin. he may have a different approach and may have even added that line but forgive and stick together please so we can focus on who is the real enemy and do what we need to have Hashem favor us, each with our own derech. becaue of slifkin i was able to easily give a fair amount of tzedaka which i'm sure helped many. let's keep our fighting out, even what we normally understand to be l'maan Hashem. right now the l'maan Hashem is to only argue about fundamentals and in a calm way and keep our eye on the ball. unity is not just a nice concept; it's part of teshuva with Hashem wants right now.

shulman's avatar

and i'm only saying this to you, not to those on this blog who have a real point to make about our derech, even if i disagree with their approach at this time. and i have only respect for you for doing what you feel is kvod Hashem, for real, i'm on your side, i'm just asking if we can try to come together here

thanks. may we see no more חילול כבוד שמים וישראל and may we see no more suffering

User's avatar
Comment removed
Oct 9, 2023
Comment removed
Uriah’s Wife's avatar

@sender,

What exactly is it that I don’t know what I’m talking about? If you were honest, instead of just being dismissive, you’d buttress your position with a cogent response instead of simply saying that I be cancelled. That really doesn’t support your argument.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Oct 9, 2023
Comment removed
Natan Slifkin's avatar

"Gedolei Torah, who know a lot more than you or me have made it clear that they hold that one can dedicate himself to full time learning and, al pi Halacha, he is exempt from the army in accordance to the psak of the Rambam."

These are the same Gedolim who believe that Rambam was of the view that Chazal were infallible in science. They don't have a clue what Rambam actually held and they don't really want to know.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Oct 10, 2023
Comment removed
Ephraim's avatar

"NOBODY thinks Chazal were infallible in science."

A lot of nobodies out there.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Oct 11, 2023
Comment removed
User's avatar
Comment removed
Oct 9, 2023
Comment removed
Natan Slifkin's avatar

No, the "zechus torah" of those who avoid their responsibilities is not remotely as important as the mobilization of the IDF. It's like people who learn Torah on erev Shabbos instead of helping their wives.

shulman's avatar

do you believe in teshuva tefila u'tzedaka...?

Natan Slifkin's avatar

Absolutely. I hope that they will do teshuva.

shulman's avatar

So isn't intensifying learning and doing what God wants a major part of that?

Just as the idf needs to mobilize, we believe that it is equally/more important to strengthen our service of God...

User's avatar
Comment removed
Oct 9, 2023
Comment removed
s. kossin's avatar

I'm just curiously asking, has Rabbi Natan Slifkin served? Not his kids, but the Rabbi himself? If not, maybe join right now? ("They won't accept me" is a lame excuse. Go ahead and offer them your conscription.)

Second question: would the Museum ever have come about? Or would there be a different museum, one discussing the calibre of ammunition required to pierce the armour of a Russian T-80....

All of that aside, probably, if given a choice, many very kind and responsible Charedi Yeshiva students would actually like to serve. There are other issues preventing them- mostly political in nature. I cannot even place all of the blame on the Roshei Yeshivos. The Army leadership itself is very opposed to accommodating Charedi recruits in regular units. Go figure.

Hint: What it is that makes a person good at killing people, is not what makes a good Yeshiva Scholar.

Can we find other military responsibilities that are intellectual, and go alongside a Torah-studying lifestyle? It's an open question. But I think there are, and the IDF would know. That is where you should be looking.

--------

I just want to conclude with an analogy; one a little different from yours, of the Kollel Scholar who doesn't help with the Shabbos preparations. The Scholar wanted to help, but was told he must do so in a way that was contrary to either his beliefs or his abilities. He tried asking for some changes, but his wife flatly refused. After giving up hope, he went back to studying. While not perfect, it is far more accurate.

Garvin's avatar

Terrible analogy.

There are videos circulating right now of the Israeli army boasting how its fences and sophisticated defenses made Israel impregnable. And yet with bare bones equipment costing .00001% of the defense budget, they came right on through.

Nissim Black said it best, in a simple sentence: "We need the army, but the army needs God."

Garvin's avatar

And upon just a minute's additional reflection, hasn't that exact same point been made by the Bible, over and over and over?

Uriah’s Wife's avatar

@ Garvin,

So where was god yesterday when Yidden needed him the most? During our recent Yom Kipur, it appears that your breast-beating supplications were insufficient to stir god’s empathy and altruism in Israel’s favor.

So which of god’s implorations were you deficient in? Was it Tshuvah or Tfillah or Tzedakah? Maybe all three or only 2 of the 3 or perhaps just 1. Wouldn’t it be nice for god to tell you which of the three supplications you were deficient in before deciding to kill thousands of blameless Yidden.

Yeah. It’s all your fault.

David Ilan's avatar

We need God but we don’t need shirkers.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Oct 9, 2023
Comment removed
Natan Slifkin's avatar

The mistake you make is in thinking that zechus Hatorah comes specifically from the people who should be serving in the army, as opposed to all the other people who are learning Torah

Ephraim's avatar

"Noson Jesus"

המכנה את חברו... אין לו חלק לעולם הבא

Yekutiel Weiss's avatar

RNS believes in Torah and preaches accordingly. He criticizes what he believes is lacking.You have your approach and he has his.Are you an Apikorus?!

User's avatar
Comment removed
Oct 10, 2023
Comment removed
Ephraim's avatar

I hope there was a call up that all Yeshiva and Kollel students should immediately return to the Bais Medrash and not wait until Rosh Chodesh.

Indeed there was:

https://www.kikar.co.il/yeshiva-world/s26hh0

David Ilan's avatar

Fill up the coffee pots! Warm those chairs! Like they are really doing anything. 126 soldiers so far have paid the supreme price. They are cowered and shirkers.

Uriah’s Wife's avatar

@sender

Yeah, all that zechus hatorah didn’t deter Hamas from its genocidal butchery as is evidenced by all those useless zechusim throughout the years of holocaust.

All those thousands of yeshiva and kollel folks studying holy 4th century tort law didn’t count for a hill of beans, all those zechusim a worthless palaver of self delusion and pretext not to subject themselves to the dangers facing Israeli soldiers.

When levelheaded Jews see the idiocy spouted by Sender they make just one brucha every day — she’assani secular. And it’s one great reason that the majority of Jews are off the derech and want no association with chareidi/Orthodox society.

Mikhail Olivson's avatar

At another time, I'd argue with you. Now, I'd simply suggest you save your anger for the real enemy. Shalom, sister. In the truest meaning of the word.

shulman's avatar

My comment is for you and no one else, so I'm editing it. It should still be in your email...