Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Fluffy Cloud of Goodness's avatar

Rabbi Slifkin, as I said in a different comment, there is a great deal of anger against Hamas right now. They perpetrated a terrible blow against the people of Israel. People are fed up and frustrated with them, and the rage has reached a boiling point. Although in normal times, the rule of law applies, these are not normal times. What does Judaism say about extrajudicial punishment? As with many things, the answer is not black-and-white. Historically there has been much discussion on this topic. The concept may be controversial, but it too has its place, especially in times like this. Obviously, this doesn't automatically acquit the soldiers, especially if they engaged in the terrible act of משכב זכר. But it's important to remember the context before jumping to conclusions, or reflexively putting full faith and trust in liberal judges over soldiers who paid in blood and tears.

Expand full comment
Leib Shachar's avatar

After reading the long list of issues (A-I) The main issue was not even mentioned, and that is that in midst of a war with Hamas, all the court cares about is what some IDF soldiers did in the heat of the moment.

Expand full comment
95 more comments...

No posts