Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Colonel of Truth's avatar

If Reform Jews have gone "off the derech" in an extreme, secular way, then I think we need to admit the chareidim have gone "off the derech" in an extreme, religious way. Going "off the derech" can go both ways.

Expand full comment
Jeremy Topaz's avatar

I believe the problem is the rabbis whom the yeshiva students obey. They don't obey the laws of the land because they are told that is their enemy. We don't have the resources to arrest many draft-dodgers, and to handle the protests that ensue. Their rabbis who incite to non-enlisting should either be arrested (if their is a law against encitement to commit a crime) or should be gathered to a meeting at which they should be convinced of the immorality and non-sustainability of their policy. If they refuse to order those who can to enlist, they should go to jail.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts