Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ephraim's avatar

The post is mostly is a about failures on the right. Necessarily so, since the right has been in power for years.

Among the failures of the gov't RNS mentions is the neglect of security down south, the over-reliance of imported military equipment and the lack of domestic production of arms, and dismal communication skills. Tone deafness does appear to be a prerequisite for politicians, and is an affliction that affect both sides of the political spectrum.

But has the left really been an advocate for bringing home arms production? Did they sound the alarm about security for the south?

Has the left answered Ben Gvir's citizen arming scheme with one that would include background checks & proper training? Or are they against any loosening of Israel's very restrictive gun control?

(And does it matter anymore? Does the left still exist?)

Expand full comment
Nachum's avatar

As the commenters below note, you seem quite concerned with American military aid, but you have it exactly backwards. I'm not sure you realize that American "support" is what keeps Israel from developing its own weapons. Israel's weapons industry, and its export of same, would be much more unfettered if it didn't receive American "aid," which actually amounts to exactly *zero* dollars (I know, it's hard to believe, but look it up) outside of what Israel *must* spend in the US. At least part of that is a way of American politicians paying off the domestic defense industry without it being too obvious. There are a lot of political considerations at play here. The American aid helps AIPAC feel important, it helps American Jews feel that they are doing something, it's a way for American politicians to get Jewish votes and support while also throwing around a lot of pork...and any Israeli general who criticizes it soon finds himself out of a job, because there are a lot of political interests in Israel as well.

Don't believe me? One word: Lavi. Look it up.

As to the "concentrating on Judea and Samaria," that is a blood libel that was disproven almost immediately but which the Left won't drop, for obvious reasons. (For starters, it allows them to ignore that *they* were the ones pushing Oslo, and the Disengagement, and constant appeasement and money to Hamas. The last of course they've decided to blame on Bibi.) There was no withdrawal of IDF forces from the Gaza area. In fact, they went up. Were there soldiers in Judea and Samaria? Of course, because- get this- *there are Jews there*. And you may have forgotten, but the news up to October 7 was *full* of stories of terror attacks on the West Bank, along with all sorts of blood libels about attacks by "settlers" on Arabs and *something has to be done*. (Such libels are of course still ongoing. And the IDF has gotten much *more* active in the West Bank since October 7.)

There's lots of blame to go around, right up to the top. But this lazy and ugly blaming of the "settlers" for October 7 really, *really* ought to stop.

As for right-wing logic, it's really very simple: The less Arabs in our land, the less terror (and crime) we'll have to face. You may not like that, you may have a million arguments against it, but try to argue with the logic.

Expand full comment
203 more comments...

No posts