Which is a more respectful approach towards a Rishon whose view one finds deeply problematic: (A) Quoting him, explaining why he took this view, and respectfully explaining why one disagrees with his view and prefers the view of other Rishonim. (B) Sharply criticizing the approach itself without letting on that it was the view of this Rishon.
Respecting Rishonim
Respecting Rishonim
Respecting Rishonim
Which is a more respectful approach towards a Rishon whose view one finds deeply problematic: (A) Quoting him, explaining why he took this view, and respectfully explaining why one disagrees with his view and prefers the view of other Rishonim. (B) Sharply criticizing the approach itself without letting on that it was the view of this Rishon.