Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Moshe's avatar

Now this is what I come to this blog for! This is great content. Interesting, rationalist, and very well explained. Great stuff. Thank you.

Expand full comment
דוד™️'s avatar

Well written as usual, and fascinating topic.

It's interesting because Rashi (סנהדרין דל"ג א' וש"ך סי' כ"ה סק"ט) happens to sound like טעה בדבר משנה is only an actual משנה not a מציאות...

But more to the point, it's interesting to me that this was a חידוש to you. Rashi's allowed to make mistakes and be wrong just like ר' טרפון is allowed to make mistakes and be wrong.

(ר טרפון thought that taking the womb out renders the בהמה a טריפה, possibly because they didn't have sophisticated enough surgeries, but the חכמים disagreed because of תודוס הרופא's account that חזירה לא היתה יוצאת ממצרים אא"כ ניטל האם שלה and so ר טרפון was wrong and called a טועה בדבר משנה since it was undisputable (ע' ש"ך שם).)

I haven't specifically learned that sugya yet (thanks for the מראה מקומות) but if we still pasken like rashi, there must be more to it.

Basically, I really enjoyed the article (though I am unfamiliar with the topic and still have to look into it myself) but why did you insert in the previous post strange undertones that this has to do with a 'rational' world view? Unless you really don't get our side.

Hopefully, now that you are getting it more - welcome!! 😊

Expand full comment
80 more comments...

No posts