Rewriting Jewish Intellectual History: A Review of Sefer Chaim Be’Emunasom Part 4: Rambam on the Definition of Torah from Sinai Chapter 10 of Chaim B’Emunasam is dedicated to showing that “every dispute, question and opinion in Shas was given at Sinai.” According to R. Schmeltzer, one is obligated to accept that when there is a dispute or question in the Gemara, every position was received by Moshe Rabbeinu at Har Sinai. I was utterly bewildered to see R. Schmeltzer citing Rambam’s introduction to his
Rambam on Machlokes
Rambam on Machlokes
Rambam on Machlokes
Rewriting Jewish Intellectual History: A Review of Sefer Chaim Be’Emunasom Part 4: Rambam on the Definition of Torah from Sinai Chapter 10 of Chaim B’Emunasam is dedicated to showing that “every dispute, question and opinion in Shas was given at Sinai.” According to R. Schmeltzer, one is obligated to accept that when there is a dispute or question in the Gemara, every position was received by Moshe Rabbeinu at Har Sinai. I was utterly bewildered to see R. Schmeltzer citing Rambam’s introduction to his