Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Frankie's avatar

You forgot to mention the delusion of thinking deep seated delusions of millions of people the world over will be solved by a blog post.

You do realize this reads like a Purim spiel, don't you? The left is delusional in thinking the Palestinians will do this, the right is delusional in thinking the Palestinians will do that, the West is delusional in thinking the Israelis will do somesuch and that Palestinians will do whatnot.

So my solution is that the Palestinians should do that the Israelis should do this, the West should believe whatchamacallit, and the UN should disband. Ok? Everybody snap to it now.

Dude, get used it it. You don't have a solution, and neither does anybody else. The Israelis are in an absolutely impossible situation al pi derech haTeva. They are living surrounded by millions who DON'T WANT A SOLUTION. And millions more of the same are embedded in the State itself. And the "West" - the institutions, intelligentsia, and media that runs it - don't seriously want to work for a solution either. Lose your delusions and come to terms with the fact that this is a problem with no solution. We're stuck forever in maintenance and damage control mode, and hope for rachamei shamayim.

This is a reality lost on those who post delusional statements like "I went into a fruit store in Machaneh Yehuda yesterday and saw a ripe pomegranate. If this is galut then I don't know what geulah looks like". But the rest of us just have to come to terms with reality.

Expand full comment
shulman's avatar

The issues (delusions) are very well presented, and the solution is what absolutely need to happen. But effectively, there are so many variables that are unfortunately completely unrealistic. Deradicalizing Palestinians is actually like 'deradicalizing' chareidim - people with sincere religious beliefs. (I only say that in this context; in just about any other context I'd say this about religious Jews in general...) We can keep trying to figure this stuff out at it shabbos tables and hope for the best.

But if we're being brutally honest, the only true solution is for all of us to do teshuva. I promise that will help...

Expand full comment
262 more comments...

No posts