Discussion about this post

User's avatar
דוד™️'s avatar

Very nice post! And (as always) very well written. Great message.

We can amicably quibble about small details, such as your sweeping statements about the oven of Achnai which is far more nuanced than presented, or your understanding of when and how certain things are accepted להלכה which is a big giant sugya with a whole range of opinions and pretty definite outcomes, see Rosh in Sanhedrin 4:6 for starters.

But the gist was very nice. Shkoyach!

Enjoy the feast!

Expand full comment
Shaul Shlomo Daus's avatar

Do you have a source for your understanding of the achnai gemara? That's not how the concept of lo bashamayim was explained to me, but I definitely don't claim a comprehensive familiarity with the topic.

I don't understand your approach though. If the bas kol represents the absolute objective truth, why indeed didn't the majority change their position accordingly? Why would they argue on an objective truth?

Expand full comment
294 more comments...

No posts