Monday, June 14, 2021

The Prime Ministers' Speeches

There were two amazing speeches that were not heard this week. One was that of new prime minister Naftali Bennett, whose speech was drowned out by heckling. The other was that of alternate prime minister Yair Lapid, who opted not to give his speech after the circus surrounding Bennett's speech. Both these speeches deserve to be heard, and are printed below. I personally found them tremendously inspirational, and I hope you do too.

Full text of Naftali Bennett's speech:

His Excellency President Reuven Rivlin; President-elect Isaac Herzog; Mr. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu; President of the Supreme Court, Justice Esther Hayat; Speaker of the Knesset Yariv Levin; my partner in forming the Unity Government, Member of Knesset Yair Lapid, and his wife Lihi; Ministers of the outgoing government; Ministers of the incoming government; Members of Knesset; honored guests.
 
I want to begin my words by saying, on my own behalf, and in the name of the members of the designated government, in the name of this House, and in the name of all the citizens of Israel – thank you. Thank you to the outgoing Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, for your many years of service, replete with achievements, for the sake of the State of Israel. As Prime Minister you acted throughout many years to embolden Israel’s political, security, and economic strength. I saw you from up-close, in extensive security deliberations, late into the night, investigating, making inquiries and considerations out of a sense of grave responsibility. 
Benjamin and Sara Netanyahu, over the years, we have not always agreed, but we have both sacrificed much on a personal level in order to serve our people, the people of Israel. Expressing gratitude is a fundamental principle in Judaism. This is the time for the people to say to you, thank you.
 
I also want to take this opportunity to express my deep appreciation to the Tenth President of the State of Israel, Reuven Rivlin, for his years as President, as Speaker of the Knesset, and as a public servant. And to congratulate President-elect, Isaac Herzog, and wish him much success. God willing, we will work together very well.
 
Honored ladies and gentlemen, this is a special moment. The moment in which the baton of leading the people and the country passes – as in a relay race – to the next generation. It a sacred endowment. 
 
The State of Israel is not ‘just another country’. It is the dream of generations of Jews – from Marrakesh to Budapest, from Bagdad to San Francisco – a dream we merited to see realized every day before our very eyes. Each generation has its own challenges, and out of each generation comes the leaders that can overcome them.
 
The external challenges we face are great: the Iranian nuclear project, which is moving towards a crucial point; the ongoing war on terror; Israel's image in the world and the unfair treatment it receives in international institutions – these are all sizable and complex tasks.
At this time, we are also facing an internal challenge. The ongoing rift in the nation, as we see in these very moments, which continues to rip apart the seams that hold us together, and has thrown us – one election after another – into a maelstrom of hatred and in-fighting. 
Such quarrels, between the people who are supposed to be running the country, led to paralysis. One who quarrels, cannot function. 
 
And so Israel ceased to be managed: a lack of governance in the Negev and loss of the South for 12 years, riots in mixed cities, the lack of state budget, the terrible disaster in Meron.
Dear friends, in the guests gallery today, sits Maya Moreno, widow of my friend, Lieutenant Colonel Emmanuel Moreno, of blessed memory. At every important juncture of my life, I think of Emmanuel. The intensity of his devotion and sense of mission guides us.
 
Friends, as the Jewish people tend to be people with opinions… and as we see here, the Parliament of the Jewish state, is a parliament of opinions, and anyone who has ever seen a pair of students studying Talmud together, or a heated debate about a product in the office corridors of an Israeli start-up, understands the force for good of “disputes for the sake of Heaven”. But there are points in Jewish history in which the disagreements between us have gone out of control, in which they were no longer “disputes for the sake of Heaven”, times in which they threatened us, and all that we have built with our sweat and blood.
 
Twice in history, we have lost our national home precisely because the leaders of the generation were not able to sit with one and another and compromise. Each was right, yet with all their being right, they burnt the house down on top of us. I am proud of the ability to sit together with people with very different views from my own.
 
This time, at the decisive moment, we have taken responsibility. We understood that we have to safeguard our home. To continue on in this way – more elections, more hatred, more vitriolic posts on Facebook – is just not an option. Therefore, we stopped the train, a moment before it barreled into the abyss. And I want to thank my friend, Foreign Minister-designate, MK Yair Lapid, who showed national responsibility, political generosity, and without whom we would not be here today.
 
The time has come for different leaders, from all parts of the people, to stop, to stop this madness.
 
The government that will be formed represents many of Israel’s citizens: from Ofra to Tel Aviv, from Rahat to Kiryat Shmona. Precisely here lies the opportunity. Our principle is, we will sit together, and we will forge forward on that which we agree – and there is much we agree on, transport, education and so on, and what separates us we will leave to the side.
 
To the citizens of Israel I say: this is a sensitive moment, of political change. I call on all, to demonstrate maturity and restraint. 
 
The new government will be a government which strives for real, practical solutions, to the problems faced by the country and its citizens. The work-plan which we are presenting today is the most detailed in years. We have come to work. To remove the barriers, to free up the jams, and to turn our country into what it can be.
 
The following, are some of the things the government will promote immediately:
 
We will take responsibility for the education of Israeli children from birth. The most formative years. As a first step, we will transfer responsibility for infant daycare to the Ministry of Education.
 
We will enable many ultra-Orthodox youth to go out to work by lowering the (national service) exemption age from 24 to 21. Not by force, but by positive encouragement, allowing young people who want to learn a vocation to be able to, and those who want to study Torah will continue to do so.
 
We will close with immediate effect the Ministry of Digital Affairs, the Ministry for Water, the Ministry for Communal Advancement, and the Ministry for Strategic Affairs.
 
Foreign Minister-designate and Alternate Prime Minister-designate, Yair Lapid, will lead a process to rehabilitate the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, which is a fundamental tool for building Israel’s political strength.
 
Finance Minister-designate Avigdor Lieberman, will lead a plan by which we will return to work those who lost their employment due to COVID-19. We will bring in as many people as possible in the high-tech industry, where there are higher salaries, by setting a national target of raising the number of high-tech workers to 15% of the workforce by 2026.
 
We will reduce superfluous regulation and frustrating bureaucracy, and we will work for citizen-friendly government services, as in Singapore among other countries – without paperwork, without queues.  
 
We will make life easier for independent workers and small business owners, including through unemployment benefits.
 
We will increase income support for the elderly to 70% of the minimum wage.
 
We will open up competition in Kashrut (kosher certification), and set standards for the system. This will lighten the burden on restaurant owners, ending the stranglehold monopoly in this area, bringing down the cost of food, and strengthening the public’s faith in the level of Kashrut.
 
Justice Minister-designate Gideon Saar will lead a process to create an appropriate balance between the judicial, legislative, and executive branches of government, whereby his initiative to split the role of the Attorney General is a significant first step.
 
We will – finally – promote a national plan for the North of Israel, including establishing a hospital and a university in the Galilee.
 
Defense Minister Benny Gantz will lead a process to significantly strengthen and build up the IDF through a multi-year plan, which will include significant investment in offensive and defensive capabilities. We must invest because the threats will not leave us. Our soldiers deserve the best and most advanced equipment in the world.
 
We will work to upgrade Israel’s public transport system, led by Transport Minister-designate Merav Michaeli.
 
We will strengthen the building of communities across the Land of Israel.
 
We will ensure Israel’s national interests in Area C – and we will increase standards to that end after much neglect in this area.
 
And yes my friends, we will open a new page in the relations between the State of Israel and the country’s Arab citizens. The Arab community will be represented in the coalition by Mansour Abbas and his party. This is a process that I must give credit to Prime Minister Netanyahu who held a groundbreaking series of meetings with Mansour Abbas, who reached out a hand. This was the right thing to do. We understand the plight and needs of the Arab society. The fight against crime and violence, the housing crisis, the gaps in education and infrastructure – will be addressed.
 
We will begin the process of regulating the Bedouin settlements in the Negev, so that Israel’s Bedouin citizens can live in dignity. 
 
Health Minister-designate Nitzan Horowitz, will prepare the health system for a new age of community, and home based medical care, and together we will prepare an emergency plan in the case of future pandemics. You can’t always know there will be a vaccine, not every illness has a vaccine, and you have to be prepared to build on vaccinations, but also on an organized plan and not as we saw in the last year.
 
We will accelerate the pace of building homes in Israel. The government will take the initiative, remove obstacles, and allow for extensive construction throughout the country, in order to but the breaks on the rise in the cost of housing. There has been a slowdown in the building of houses in the last year – we should be seeing the opposite – we should have increased the building, there is a deficit in housing which drives up the prices, and no propaganda will hide that. Therefore we will up the pace of building to but the brakes on the rise in prices, and allow young people – who serve in the army, fulfil reserve duty, pay their taxes, and have no chance of building a house. So yes, we need to deal with this.
 
The government will work to promote Jewish immigration (Aliyah) to Israel, and the best integration for them.
 
We will strengthen the bond between the State of Israel, and the Jews of the Diaspora. We will care for our brothers and sisters around the world, we will fight against the wave of antisemitism.
 
We will safeguard the State of Israel, the nation state of the Jewish people, as a Jewish and democratic state.
 
And that is just part of our plans. As I said, we have come to work! For everyone.
 
From here, I turn to the ultra-Orthodox community. Although the ultra-Orthodox parties chose not to join the coalition, that does not mean you are not represented - I will represent you, we will represent you. The new government will respect the study of Torah, the Torah which kept us safe for so many years in exile, and at the same time will work to remove the barriers which prevent the ultra-Orthodox community’s integration into the employment market, and Israeli society. Instead of perpetuating the same methods, we will have the opportunity to address the deep problems which burden ultra-Orthodox society: key amongst them the housing crisis. The pace of construction of apartments, neighborhoods, and cities simply does not keep up with natural growth, and there is room for the establishment of new ultra-Orthodox neighborhoods and even a new city in Israel.
 
I was asked by the father of Eliyahu Shmuel, of blessed memory – a 16 year old ultra-Orthodox boy, who was killed in the Meron Disaster – to remember him in my swearing in address. Eli was a sweet child. He always helped his friends, and saw the good in everyone. We will not forget Eli, and we will not ignore his death. A State Commission of Inquiry will be set up.
 
Honored ladies and gentlemen. The government is setting out on its path, as the greatest threat to Israel, the Iranian nuclear project, is reaching a critical point. The Middle East is still yet to recover from the effects of the first nuclear deal, which emboldened Iran to the tune of billions of dollars, and with international legitimacy.
 
Iran, through its Quds Force of the Revolutionary Guard, has established terrorist outposts - from Syria, through Gaza and Lebanon, and to Yemen. Renewing the nuclear deal with Iran is a mistake that will once again lend legitimacy to one of the most discriminatory and violent regimes in the world.
 
Israel will not allow Iran to be equipped with nuclear weapons. Israel is not party to the agreement, and will maintain full freedom to act.
 
Last month, we received a reminder that the conflict with the Palestinians is still here. We must remember, and remind the world, that our enemies deny our very existence in the Land of Israel, and that this is not a dispute over territory.
 
We need military strength, civil resilience, and a belief in the justness of our path at times when the conflict raises its head.
 
I hope the ceasefire in the south is maintained. But if Hamas again chooses the path of violence against Israeli civilians, it will encounter a wall of iron.
 
Violence and terrorism are not a natural phenomenon or destiny with which we are supposed to just come to terms. The Palestinians must take responsibility for their actions, and understand that violence will be met with a firm response.
 
That said, security calm will lead to economic moves, which will lead to reducing friction and the conflict.
 
To the Goldin, Shaul, Mengistu, and Sayed families. The government led by me will work to bring home the IDF’s fallen, and the Israeli citizens held in Gaza by Hamas. We see in their return a sacred duty, which should be undertaken out of responsibility. 
 
The government will work to establish and expand peace agreements with the Arab states, to increase regional economic, entrepreneurial, and cultural cooperation, and to deepen the direct connection between the peoples of the region, such as the connection between the citizens of Israel and the citizens of the United Arab Emirates.
 
Dear friends, on behalf of us all, I want to thank the President of the United States of America, Joe Biden, for standing alongside Israel during the last operation in Gaza, “Guardian of the Walls”, and for his longstanding commitment to the security of Israel.
 
President Biden said during the operation, “Until the region says, unequivocally, they acknowledge the right of Israel to exist as an independent Jewish state, there will be no peace”.
 
It is important that this message be heard, and internalized, in the Middle East.
We greatly appreciate the support of the United States, our greatest friend. My government will make an effort to deepen and nurture relations with our friends in both parties – bipartisan. If there are disputes, we will manage them with fundamental trust, and mutual respect.
My fellow Members of Knesset, in light of the ongoing turbulent debate, the people are looking to the House. Let us maintain respectful debate. I understand those for whom today is difficult, but friends, this is not a day of mourning. There is no Disengagement here. There is no harm being caused to anyone. There is a change of government in a democracy. That’s it. And I assure it is a government that will work for the sake of all the people. We will do all we can so that no one should have to feel afraid. We are here in the name of good, and to work. And I say to those who intend to celebrate tonight, don’t dance on the pain of others. We not enemies, we are one people.
 
Now, hours before accepting this responsibility, I pray to God that He grant me wisdom and understanding to lead the State of Israel.
 
“Heavenly Father, Rock and Redeemer of Israel, bless the State of Israel, the first flourishing of our redemption, guard it in your abundant kindness, spread over it the shelter of Your peace. Send forth your light and truth to its leaders, ministers, and advisors, and grace them with Your good counsel. Strengthen the hands of those who guard our holy land, grant them deliverance, and adorn them in victory. Give peace in the land, and grant its inhabitants eternal happiness.”
 
With God’s help, we will do and we will succeed. Amen.
 
Members of Knesset, I am now honored to present before you the government what we have formed, in alphabetical order (in Hebrew).
 
Naftali Bennett – Prime Minister and Minister for Settlement Affairs
Yair Lapid – Minister of Foreign Affairs, and Alternate Prime Minister
Ministers affiliated with the Prime Minister:
Ayelet Shaked – Minister of the Interior
Gideon Sa'ar – Minister of Justice
Ze’ev Elkin – Minister of Housing and Construction, Minister of Jerusalem and Heritage, and Minister Responsible for Government Liaison with the Knesset
Yoaz Hendel – Minister of Communications
Yifat Shasha-Biton – Minister of Education
Matan Kahana – Minister for Religious Affairs
Ministers affiliated with the Alternate Prime Minister:
Avigdor Lieberman – Minister of Finance
Orit Farkash HaCohen – Minister of Science and Technology
Orna Barbivai – Minister of Economy
Benjamin Gantz – Minister of Defense
Hili Tropper – Minister of Culture and Sport
Hamad Amar – Minister in the Finance Ministry
Yoel Razvozov – Minister of Tourism 
Meir Cohen – Minister of Labour, Welfare, and Social Services
Meirav Cohen – Minister of Social Equality
Merav Michaeli – Minister of Transport and Road Safety
Nachman Shai – Minister of Diaspora Affairs
Nitzan Horowitz – Minister of Health
Oded Forer – Minister of Agriculture and Development, and Minister of the Periphery, the Negev and the Galilee
Issawi Frej – Minister for Regional Cooperation
Omer Bar Lev – Minister for Internal Security
Pnina Tamano Shata – Minister for Immigration and Absorption
Karine Elharrar – Minister for Energy
Tamar Zandberg – Minister for Environmental Protection
 
The date of the handover between the Prime Minister and the Alternate Prime Minister is August 27, 2023. I request, Mr. Speaker, that the Members of the Knesset express their support for the Unity Government, so that we may begin to restore stability and functionality to the State of Israel. Thank you.
 
 
Mr. President, Mr. Speaker, Knesset, Prime Minister Designate, outgoing Prime Minister, President of the Supreme Court, honored guests.

In the Book of Judges, the phrase “the land was peaceful for 40 years” appears three times. I don’t know what will happen in 40 years, but let us all hope that in the future, we will be able to say of the government we are forming today: “the land was peaceful for 40 years.”

Because that is what we need. Israel is hurting. It is time for peace in this land.

In a democratic country, governments rise and fall. A generation goes and a generation comes. That is the natural order of things. This is a complicated coalition, maybe the most complicated in the country’s history, but the reason for its creation is actually simple: it is time.

It’s time. It is even a little late. This change is unavoidable because time does not stop. It’s time to change the operating system; it’s time for a change of generation.

But before we look to the future, we have another task — we need to find a way to forgive one another for the past. Hate is a prison, and forgiveness is the way out.

I look at the past few years in the life of this country: the protests, the anger, the terrible things that have been said in this hall. I don’t want to be held hostage by those years.

In the past six years, I have sat in the opposition. Much of that time, I have been angry at the way the government treated us. The solution is not to treat them the same way. The solution is to behave differently.

I want to say to the opposition from this podium — our door will be open to you. We know that the public that voted for you has real needs. We won’t agree on everything, but we will always listen.

The past few years have seen us all turned from people into labels — right, left, secular, Haredi, Jewish, Arab. This government has been formed so that we stop being labels and revive our common identity, people, with all our complexities.

One of the Haredi Knesset Members sent me a message just before Shabbat which said, “The Kotzker Rebbe defined the saying, ‘Just as their faces are not the same, so their opinions are not the same’ as meaning, ‘Just as no person is angry that his friend has a different face, so no person should be angry at his friend’s different opinions.’” And then he added: “Let us hope for days of common good.”

If the Kotzker Rebbe had known his words would become a WhatsApp message full of good intentions between two Knesset Members, one Haredi and one secular, in a free and democratic Israel, then I think he would have been pleased. I believe he would have said to us, “It cannot be that you do not see how close you are.” We have an argument between us over politics and values, but we are not enemies. We live here together. Our fate is intertwined.

After all the insults and the warnings, the real divide in Israeli society isn’t between left and right. The real divide is between moderates and extremists. Those who want to build and those who want to destroy.

We will not let the extremists destroy the State of Israel. We will not let hate control us. Violent racists do not become patriots just because they wrap themselves in a flag. They will not define for us what it means to love Israel.

We are not enemies. Even the most strident opinions, even the most heated arguments, will not turn us into enemies. We will not let extremists destroy our ability to speak to one another and to work together for the good of the country.

Melanie Klein, one of the great psychoanalysts, explained that, corresponding to the desire to destroy, people also have a desire to repair. We have within us something strong that seeks to heal the world and ourselves. This government was formed out of that desire.
 
We have a lot to fix.

We have to fix the discourse between us and we have to fix the sidewalks in Taybeh. We have to fix the internal medicine departments in our hospitals and the internal divides on religion and state. We have to fix our democracy and our relations with the Democratic Party in the United States. We have to fix the social gaps, and ensure that every child in Israel has a computer, and high-speed internet, and an equal opportunity to succeed.

It’s a lot of work. We have a lot of work to do. The only way to succeed is to work together. The cynics will mock — they always do — but cynics have never created anything.

If you want to build something, to create something, you need to trust other people. No home — a private one or a national one — was ever built by one person alone. The architect needs the engineer, the engineer needs the builder, the builder needs the brickmaker. This government was formed because we believe that our role is to build something better together. We believe that what connects us — what makes us one people and one nation and one country — is taking responsibility.

We are not only creating a government today, but also going back to the basic truth that our role is not only to look after ourselves, but also to look after one another. To care not only for people who think like us, but for all those who walk the Israeli journey with us.

This government was not formed for politicians. It was formed for teachers and engineers, farmers and police officers, small business owners, and Holocaust survivors, and school children.

It is being formed for Meital, the young woman with a nose piercing who stopped me in the street and said, “I didn’t vote for you, but you owe me.” And she’s right. I do owe her. Because she is the legal owner of the future we are being entrusted to build.

People ask us, what do you have in common? What is there in common between Merav Michaeli and Avigdor Liberman? What is there in common between Ayelet Shaked and Benny Gantz and Mansour Abbas? Between Gideon Sa’ar and Nitzan Horowitz? What is there in common between Yair Lapid and Naftali Bennett?

The answer is — this country. That is the thing that unites us. That’s our shared love. None of us thinks that we love the country more than the other. None of us has ownership over patriotism or love of the country.

What we have in common is the understanding that you cannot claim to love Israel if you hate half of the Israelis.

There is nothing easier than finding common ground between us, if you know where to look. The care for small businesses in the periphery. The importance we place on the education of our children and the healthcare of our parents. The understanding that the IDF needs to be strong and uphold clear moral values. The recognition that this country is governed by the rule of law and that we need to show zero tolerance to corruption, especially in the public sector. The understanding that it is the duty of the Jewish state to ensure civic equality for every citizen.

There is one more thing that we have in common; when something is broken we don’t look for someone to blame, but for a way to fix it. This government has come to fix what is broken. That is its role, its mission. That is the major change it brings with it.

Before I finish, I want to thank my incredible team that created and built this government: Hillel Kobrinsky, our commander, Dani Vesely, Dana Pitelis Kaduri, Naama Shultz, Gili Haushner, Yael Bar, Roei Konkol, Yair Zivan, Neta Attias, Tami Nassee, Ethel Hooven, Meir Cohen, Rami Yehudicha, Mark Mellman, Oded Gazit, and Guy Busy. Without you, it wouldn’t have happened.

Thank you to all the heads of the parties in the new coalition who came on board and worked and pushed, first and foremost my friend and partner, Prime Minister-designate Naftali Bennett. I believe in you. You will do great things for Israel.

Thank you to each of the Knesset members who brought us here today. Each of you had to show commitment and compromise. You put the country and your values before your personal interest.

I thank all the amazing people who went to stand on bridges and at junctions, they are the ones who brought us to this moment. And thank you to our Knesset members for your determination and wisdom and support.

And a final thank you to my support group, Lihi Lapid, Shulamit Lapid, my sister Merav Roth, Ilil, Yoav, Lior, and Yaeli, and to my father, who did a good job supervising from above.

Thank you.
 

45 comments:

  1. Wouldn't it be prudent for a guy like you - an orthodox yid, to NOT be inspired by a speech from the mouth of Lapid - to the point that you post it on your blog?

    I mean, I bet you see eye to eye with Lapid regarding Haredim, but I bet you don't see eye to eye with Lapid on some other VERY important topics.

    One of them is shabbos. Lapid pushed for increased transportation on Shabbos. What are your feelings on that?

    Another thing Lapd promotes is civil marriages. He prefers that Orthodox rabbis not be involved. This will allow marriages between Jews and non Jews, as well as non halachic marriages to be viewed as legitimate marriages in the state of Israel.

    He also wants negotiations with Palestinians, even a two state solution, even though history has demonstrated that it's a complete waste of time and INCREASES blood shed and destruction.

    Yet you were inspired. OK I guess there is nothing wrong with being inspired by bad people.

    But considering how nuts he is (deals with Palestinians that never work) and how anti Torah he is, isn't it possible that everything he said is hot air? Perhaps it's all talk and no action?

    And even if he is sincere, isn't it best to not allow yourself to be overly inspired by such a person?

    Oh I forgot. The haredi issue is more important than anything else, even bloodshed and shabbos desecration and intermarriage.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 1. No one ever kept shabbos more or less just because a bus is or isn't available.
      2. There is a strong logic to allowing civil unions. For one, forcing halachic marriages is more likely to result in mamzerim. The consensus of poskim (not unanimous) is that civil unions are not kidushin. This concept is not as fringe as you'd think. The late chief rabbi Bakshi Doron was of the opinion that civil marriages should be allowed. Even if you would disagree, we should have a healthy debate about this.
      3. For someone who arguing for a charedi Torah view, you should be more nuanced about land for peace. Its not a clear cut Torah view either way. Especially among charedi poskim. Either way, it is currently irrelevant. There is no Palestinian state option or peace deal on the table right now. And it is unlikely to be a real option anytime soon. Furthermore, this current gvt would not be able to make a dovish deal as there are way too many right wing parties on this issue. So this point is moot.

      Personally, I hope that these speeches were from the heart. There is way too much anger in current public discourse. We need to dial down the volume. It would be nice if this current leadership can manage this. The extreme anger from the opposition makes me wonder if they are really scared of a lower volume.

      Delete
    2. Kollel nick or whatever you are:

      You have serious issues. No one kept shabbos more or less because of a bus operating on shabbos???

      Um, how about the Jewish bus driver?

      People paying for the bus fare and carrying and more

      And how about the chilul Hashem?


      Your argument for civil marriages is pure hogwash.
      Mamzerim will be more common if marrying a nonjew is legally sanctioned

      Not sure what your spewing about peace talks. History is your teacher. It doesn't work.

      In short, you are off your rocker.

      Delete
    3. 1. No one is forcing a Jewish driver to drive on shabbos. And if he does drive a bus on shabbos, he drove his car last week too.
      2. Children from a goy are not mamzerim.
      3. You can look at poskim for Torah view of theoretical peace talks. You'll find on both sides of the issue. Either way, it's not a relevant issue right now. It's not on the table, and it is high unlikely to come up anytime soon.

      Delete
    4. CHaZaL said to learn wisdom from whomever has uttered it. Ezra thinks he knows better.

      Increased public transportation will not lead to more desecration of Shabbos. The desecration already happens. It's just different in kind. And there are non-Jews who would benefit from the availability of buses on Saturdays.

      A baby born to a non-Jewish parent isn't a Mamzer, so your assertion that legally sanctioning marriages to non-Jews would lead to such is absurd. You don't appear to know basic Halachah on this point.

      In short, you're bigoted and ignorant. Which is no surprise, as those qualities are often found in each other's company.

      Delete
    5. I find intellectually fascinating the huge discrepancies in definitions of "chilul hashem" between different sections of jewish society. Some people view it as a perceived desecration of God's name from the perspective of outsiders such as non-jews or loosely associated Jews, and others view it as a desecration from the perspective of observant jews only.

      Ezra, what is your definition of "chilul hashem"? And can you spell out how you view a bus travelling on shabbos in Israel would be a chilul hashem according to your definition?

      Delete
    6. Ezra we agree. Lapid is going to ruin the country. These liberals want to let all the Palestinians in. It's crazy stuff. At least Bennett (for now) seems to be against a two-state solution. Personally, I would love to make Bibi king. Why not? Why do we need the stupid parliamentary system, it does not work and its crazy stuff. Why do we need a democracy? Yes, these things are good but why do we even allow Arab parties? That's insane. Does Iran have a Jewish party? You can bet your silver dollar they don't. So why are we allowing an Arab party? This is ridiculous.

      I agree. Bus stops on shabbat do not do anything was desecrate G-d's name. And intermarriage and assimilation is even worse. Lapid's an atheist. He has no morals, not ethics, and no religion. Can't R. Slifkin see that Bibi is the best choice here?

      Delete
    7. Iran reserves one seat in its parliament for a Jew.

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siyamak_More_Sedgh

      Europe has long had Christian political parties.

      Delete
    8. Ok, so they have one. But it's only one. And for how long though?

      Delete
  2. The state of Israel is a purely secular entity with no shaychus to frum yiddin (from our perspective). Why do we care if they allow buses or planes to run on Shabbos? If the marriage laws would prevent a single intermarriage, then maybe that's worthwhile, but do you think that's the case? I assume they just go to Cyprus or wherever to get married anyway.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The state of Israel is a secular state but it can live according to religion, as G-d wants.

      Delete
  3. In a nutshell. Good morning.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Those were very gracious speeches. Hatzlacha to the new government.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree the speeches are inspiring. I particularly thank you for giving us Lapid's speech, which I had not seen elsewhere. Let us hope these speeches mark the start of a new and happier era in Israel's history.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lapid is going to ruin the country. How is that inspiring.

      Delete
    2. Do you live in Israel? Also I doubt this coalition is going to make it past channukah.

      Delete
  6. Replies
    1. Oh come on. Trump could make a better speech. Did you see Trump's rally last week?

      Delete
    2. No. But less me guess. Did he claim he didn't lose the election he lost?

      Delete
    3. Yes, but here's a secret. He did win the election but there was a lot of fraud.

      Delete
  7. I cannot read a speech by someone who claims to be frum but only became prime minister by deceiving his voters and breaking his word in the boldest fashion. It reminds me a story of Rav Shimon Schwab who was asked about a frum person who was cheating on his taxes. Rav Schwab said he didn't understand, so the person repeated his question. Again Rav Schwab said he didn't understand and again the person repeated the question. Finally, Rav Schwab said, "I don't understand how you can call him frum if he cheats on his taxes." I feel the same about Bennett. I think his ascendancy to the prime ministership is a huge chillul Hashem. When you wear a yarmulka on your head, you can't lie in this fashion. It's an utter disgrace and conveys the message that frumkeit has nothing to do with being a man of one's word.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The chiyuv of voting with Likud seems to have been omitted both by the Mechaber and the Rema.

      Delete
    2. Apologies I see you are upset that Bennett broke his promise not to form a government with Lapid. Although you seen less upset that Netanyahu broke his promise to form a government with Gantz.

      You can always tell when a politician is lying. Their lips move.

      That's why religion and politics make a toxic mix.

      Delete
    3. Rabbi Schwab, was indulging in the No True Scotsman Fallacy. The man who cheats on his taxes is still frum but he is committing an aveira. As the wisest of all men said כִּ֣י אָדָ֔ם אֵ֥ין צַדִּ֖יק בָּאָ֑רֶץ אֲשֶׁ֥ר יַֽעֲשֶׂה־טּ֖וֹב וְלֹ֥א יֶֽחֱטָֽא

      Delete
    4. Can you read Deri or Litzman's speeches?
      or can you only spot this problem in your political opponents?

      Delete
    5. Yeah, Bibi was so honest to us all those years. Every single day he told the truth and never did the opposite of what he said, ever. And then all of a sudden, Bennett comes along and ruins it. Seriously - get real.

      Delete
    6. I agree with your sentiment. I feel that we have caused this form of cynical politics. We have repeatedly forgiven similar actions. I didnt hear disgust from RW last year when Orly Abeksis jumped from Meretz, or when Amir Perez jumped from Avoda to prop up Netanyahu. In fact, even had Bennet agreed to join only a Netanyahu led gvt, it was banking on two rebel MKs to jump ship to bring it to 61. That would be the same exact lie that we are complaining about.
      We just had a gvt, that signed a rotation without any plan to keep to it. Religious MKs with yarmulka's guaranteed it, and didn't follow through.
      It hurts more that a man with a kipa has made this move. But that's what it became. We get the representatives that we deserve. We have become cynical, so we get cynics.


      Delete
    7. Your self-righteousness and virtue-signaling are duly noted. Now let's move forward.

      Delete
    8. And how do you feel about Litzman (under indictment) and Deri (served jail time) continuing to wear their yarmulkes? Or for that matter, about all the other chavrei kenesset from UTJ and Shas continuing to wear their yarmulkes?

      Delete
    9. Would you listen to a speech by Deri or Litzman?

      Delete
    10. I don't think he's very frum. If he is religious he is not deeply religious.

      Delete
    11. Dovid - I don't know why Litzman or Deri should remove their yarmulkes. What did they do wrong? I don't trust the political 'justice' system in Israel any more than I trust the system in Russia. Both have the same chezkat kasrhut that they had before their troubles.

      Delete
    12. Mordechai Harris - R' Schwab was making a point. He wasn't defending frumkeit as some people do: "Oh the violent uprising folk aren't real Christians," but rather saying that the person should not believe that everything he does is frum.

      At least, that is how I understand him. I was only six the last time I saw him so I didn't speak to him about this...

      Delete
  8. The incoherence of the settlers is a thing to behold.

    Bennett claims "this is not a dispute over territory." But the first half of the sentence was "We must remember, and remind the world, that our enemies deny our very existence in the Land of Israel". Um, what? So actually a dispute over territory, right.

    All very convenient. Some Palestinians don't want Israel to exist, therefore all Palestinians must be occupied by civilians.

    Earlier he says "We will ensure Israel’s national interests in Area C – and we will increase standards to that end after much neglect in this area."

    The interest in territory for someone who professes disdain for the issue is the mark of a lie. Not the lie of one man, or one party- this is the foundation lie of the entire occupation.

    Bennett has literally appointed himself the minister for settlements. For settling men women and children in another nation's land while simultaneously claiming not to have sovereignty over it. Of course according to the Rabbi Dr and the military courts these settlements are actually security installations.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "Another nation's land" tell me please, which nation is this? Jordan? Last time I checked Jordan relinquished any claims they had over Judea and Samaria.

      Delete
    2. Fine. Annexe the WB and give all residents of all races a vote. Don't take the land but only give Jews a vote.

      Delete
    3. The Hat: What do you *Really* believe the Arabs will do to us if "west bank" residents receive the right to vote in Israel and Arabs become the leading power in the country because of this boost to their demographics.
      Really, I want to know how you envision that.

      Delete
  9. Words, Timothy.
    5% of the electorate, many of whom regret being part thereof because the man they thought they voted for doesn't exist. That is called grand theft country.
    Do you really believe there is any backing for these words? Oh yes, Lapid was actually the more honest one. He will make sure we are all nice happy telly-tubbies by destroying everything Jewish in this state and if you read him carefully he is not denying it.
    The one thing Bennet will succeed in doing is destroy the Rabbinate, this is something to praise him for? So the lowest common denominator in kashrut etc goes below the floor?
    Natan, this is what Ha-shem brought us back here for?

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thank you for printing these, Rav Slifkin! They are both aspirational and inspirational.

    ReplyDelete
  11. אריה אלדד שוטר 8 יוני 21
    שלום אני אריה אלדד ואני היום השוטר הטוב
    קראתי את קוי היסוד של הממשלה החדשה ונפעמתי.
    ביצור הביטחון לצד חתירה מתמדת לשלום.
    הפחתת רגולציה, הסרת חסמים בירוקרטיים,. חיזוק עסקים קטנים ובינוניים
    קידום חוק יסוד החקיקה. .
    קידום סוגיות בנושאי דת ומדינה לגביהן יש הסכמה ציבורית רחבה.
    חוק הגיוס על פי מתוה משרד הביטחון.
    בנייה משמעותית בירושלים , ו- תחזיקו חזק - העברת כל משרדי הממשלה לירושלים
    שוויון מגדרי
    כל קשיש יקבל לפחות 70% משכר המינימום.
    ימוגר עושק הקשישים
    הגבלת כהונת ראש הממשלה לשתי קדנציות וצינון.
    אדיר. אני מבקש סליחה על כל מה שאמרתי נגד ממשלת השינוי.
    אבל... כל הדברים האלה כבר היו בקווי יסוד של הממשלות הקודמות. . אין מכס על מלים. אבל איך הפונט? אה? מה אתם אומרים?
    גם ביטחון וגם שלום. פחות רגולציה וחיזוק קטנים ובינוניים. החקיקה! מדהים. רק מי שיקבע זה ועדה עם כל השותפים, יותר כסף לקשישים . אמנם רק 430 שקל יותר. אבל יותר. וגיוס ! עכשיו כל החרדים ישרתו.
    אז מה בכל זאת חדש? הגבלת קדנציות. שכויעח.
    .

    ReplyDelete
  12. Are you seriously falling for this?June 15, 2021 at 2:34 PM

    From Yair Lapid's speech:

    "People ask us, what do you have in common? What is there in common between Merav Michaeli and Avigdor Liberman? What is there in common between Ayelet Shaked and Benny Gantz and Mansour Abbas? Between Gideon Sa’ar and Nitzan Horowitz? What is there in common between Yair Lapid and Naftali Bennett?

    The answer is — this country. That is the thing that unites us. That’s our shared love. None of us thinks that we love the country more than the other. None of us has ownership over patriotism or love of the country."


    If you can believe that Mansour Abbas and the hard left loves Israel as much as the Right, then you deserve to be fooled by smooth talking politicians.
    I wouldn't think that Rabbi Slifkin could be so hopelessly naive as to think anything coming out of a journalist/politician's mouth can be trusted enough to pull on his heart and inspire him, but I guess I was wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I could not have imagined more genuine, attentive to reality, or sensitive inauguration speeches than those I read above. Thank you Dr. Slifkin for posting them here. Every country and people should be envious of these new leaders, and in this sense I dare say it is a huge "kiddush hashem". Indeed, it is a shame that Lapid's speech was not delivered and Bennett's was drowned out by heckling. Very telling, so many haters. On this point, Lapid's line: "The real divide is between moderates and extremists. Those who want to build and those who want to destroy" rings especially true. I am now a more proud citizen of Israel than I was yesterday, and even if a small percentage of the objectives and visions laid out in both of these speeches follow to fruition, we will be a lucky people.

    ReplyDelete
  14. They were both wonderful speeches-but that is what speeches are meant to accomplish. Now we have to see how it all plays out. Personally, I have a lot of apprehension, but at the same time I believe that HaShem is in charge and will guide the affairs of State. It is correct that the divisions within our society are becoming far too extreme. We have to find a way back to believing in the State of Israel and working together to defend our homeland, make Judaism the basis for our State-without a hyphenated Judaism. There has to be room for different levels of observance; that's an issue between an individual and HaShem. It should never become a way to judge others and dismiss their relevance or give them a pass to entitlement. We have too many enemies who want to see Israel disappear; we cannot help them to achieve their goals.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Where is Bibi's speech? He is the real prime minister. The speeches were not amazing. Bennett couldn't get a sentence out. And Lapid's going to ruin the country. The Knesset is blowing up. Bennett's speech began with an auspicious beginning, foreshadowing Israel's future. This is a bad way to start. Bennett isn’t smiling now. They might not be able to have a functioning government.

    ReplyDelete
  16. @RNS, Is it possible that your disdain for bibi is blinding your should be disdain for lapid?

    ReplyDelete

Comments for this blog are moderated. Please see this post about the comments policy for details. ANONYMOUS COMMENTS WILL NOT BE POSTED - please use either your real name or a pseudonym.

Shaken By The Lulav

There are many aspects of Judaism which make people feel uncomfortable. The mitzvah of arba minim sometimes falls into that category. Shak...